{ "summary": { "projects": 11468, "registries": { "VCS": 5002, "GOLD": 4115, "CAR": 1272, "ACR": 986, "ISO": 65, "ART": 28 }, "candidates": 1989, "candidates_with_vintage_overlap": 287, "name_threshold": 0.62, "adjudicated": 450, "same_asset": 61, "same_asset_with_overlap": 18, "overlap_volume": 2486944, "needs_review": 75, "second_pass": 136, "adjudicator": "gemma-4-12b-it-qat-q4_0 (local, llama.cpp, temperature 0)", "source": "Berkeley Carbon Trading Project, Voluntary Registry Offsets Database v2026-06 (CC BY 4.0)", "merkle_root": "0xa1f9d37881368afcbcfd10f00fb57de493d8c02a356fde7f71ca5c9b75277e26", "leaf_encoding": "keccak256(abi.encode(string id, bytes32 keccak(a), bytes32 keccak(b), uint16[] vintages, uint256 overlapVolume, string verdict))" }, "findings": [ { "id": "GS7538~VCS1931", "a": "GS7538", "b": "VCS1931", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.9, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [ 2019, 2020, 2021 ], "overlap_volume": 1812874, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS7538", "Project Name": "Energising India using Solar Energy", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Solar - Centralized", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "AZURE POWER INDIA PRIVATE LIMITED", "Total Credits Issued": 1828464, "Total Credits Retired": 1346978, "issued_by_vintage": { "2019": 400699, "2020": 902275, "2021": 525490 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1931", "Project Name": "Energising India using Solar Energy Projects", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Solar - Centralized", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Azure Power India Pvt ltd", "Total Credits Issued": 4842862, "Total Credits Retired": 2516364, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 8169, "2018": 283983, "2019": 735425, "2020": 886685, "2021": 869791, "2022": 916208, "2023": 900407, "2024": 242194 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Solar - Centralized", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Solar - Centralized" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "value_b": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "AZURE POWER INDIA PRIVATE LIMITED", "value_b": "Azure Power India Pvt ltd" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS7538 vs VCS VCS1931", "Name: Energising India using Solar Energy vs Energising India using Solar Energy Projects", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Registered", "Credits issued by vintage: 2019:400699, 2020:902275, 2021:525490 vs 2017:8169, 2018:283983, 2019:735425, 2020:886685, 20" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a Renewable Energy / Solar - Centralized project in India using Methodology ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources developed by Azure Power India Pvt ltd.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xb5cd512a1157790b33c60be58bb6e0770da58d954d0c47fa0634eebf22533632", "proof": [ "0x6b46ae4f752607537365cfe0b57e697b9f1487d9e80d53ca63a08b5b2ee52753", "0x625c3e0437f5b4fa4d0ebdeaad4f0b98266317576bf09040e19c86a3d96d4180", "0xe7aa491e5c9116fcddc5057e199b9ffd7a609a810c28ed2f083f9518d8ba5abc", "0xa76977f2ee085b4f14ec73524d3446ee9177c3ecccf555d5912ac2f1f876932d", "0xd09064513da286d60121806e5b4afbc8a78acb525f8e2412451279c6808a1884", "0x5b9ccb750fb45c8ba42f45af2592f5656edc8e56e2aca0608a56c935d485b546" ] }, { "id": "GS417~VCS135", "a": "GS417", "b": "VCS135", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "China", "screen_score": 0.52, "name_sim": 0.6727, "overlap_vintages": [ 2008, 2009, 2010 ], "overlap_volume": 184738, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS417", "Project Name": "Hebei Shangyi Manjing East Wind Farm Project", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "China", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Carbon Resource Management Ltd.", "Total Credits Issued": 311368, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2007": 11249, "2008": 114520, "2009": 124830, "2010": 60769 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS135", "Project Name": "Shangyi Manjing Windfarm Project", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Late to verify", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "China", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Guohua (Hebei) Renewable Energy Co Ltd.", "Total Credits Issued": 184738, "Total Credits Retired": 177327, "issued_by_vintage": { "2008": 70908, "2009": 80992, "2010": 32838 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "China / None / None", "value_b": "China / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "value_b": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS417 vs VCS VCS135", "Name: Hebei Shangyi Manjing East Wind Farm Project vs Shangyi Manjing Windfarm Project", "Developer: Carbon Resource Management Ltd. vs Guohua (Hebei) Renewable Energy Co Ltd.", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Late to verify" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a Renewable Energy / Wind project in China using Methodology ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x6b46ae4f752607537365cfe0b57e697b9f1487d9e80d53ca63a08b5b2ee52753", "proof": [ "0xb5cd512a1157790b33c60be58bb6e0770da58d954d0c47fa0634eebf22533632", "0x625c3e0437f5b4fa4d0ebdeaad4f0b98266317576bf09040e19c86a3d96d4180", "0xe7aa491e5c9116fcddc5057e199b9ffd7a609a810c28ed2f083f9518d8ba5abc", "0xa76977f2ee085b4f14ec73524d3446ee9177c3ecccf555d5912ac2f1f876932d", "0xd09064513da286d60121806e5b4afbc8a78acb525f8e2412451279c6808a1884", "0x5b9ccb750fb45c8ba42f45af2592f5656edc8e56e2aca0608a56c935d485b546" ] }, { "id": "GS7628~VCS2244", "a": "GS7628", "b": "VCS2244", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.7, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [ 2018, 2019 ], "overlap_volume": 91977, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.95, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS7628", "Project Name": "Wind farm at Lalpur Gujarat", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Orange Renewable Power Pvt Ltd", "Total Credits Issued": 329164, "Total Credits Retired": 1810, "issued_by_vintage": { "2018": 11184, "2019": 95799, "2020": 74542, "2021": 75218, "2022": 72421 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS2244", "Project Name": "Lalpur wind farm in Gujarat", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Late to verify", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Tadas Wind Energy Private Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 275169, "Total Credits Retired": 275168, "issued_by_vintage": { "2016": 12082, "2017": 92898, "2018": 89396, "2019": 80793 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "value_b": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS7628 vs VCS VCS2244", "Name: Wind farm at Lalpur Gujarat vs Lalpur wind farm in Gujarat", "Developer: Orange Renewable Power Pvt Ltd vs Tadas Wind Energy Private Limited", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Late to verify" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a Renewable Energy / Wind project in India / None / None using Methodology ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x5e7278fee5b55e6cb61e29ba5fc96b7f7e74cc325b1653113c81b0b1e1baa200", "proof": [ "0x8372778bba1f8390056bf45ea9f206c7172ce03617eaf4e35f35098d358baef2", "0x868265bac7ac59bb52658de00e92d25c66d4aa262aee8f4c6abfa13fe588fe70", "0xe7aa491e5c9116fcddc5057e199b9ffd7a609a810c28ed2f083f9518d8ba5abc", "0xa76977f2ee085b4f14ec73524d3446ee9177c3ecccf555d5912ac2f1f876932d", "0xd09064513da286d60121806e5b4afbc8a78acb525f8e2412451279c6808a1884", "0x5b9ccb750fb45c8ba42f45af2592f5656edc8e56e2aca0608a56c935d485b546" ] }, { "id": "GS10808~VCS1683", "a": "GS10808", "b": "VCS1683", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "Senegal", "screen_score": 0.5484, "name_sim": 0.7243, "overlap_vintages": [ 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024 ], "overlap_volume": 72941, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS10808", "Project Name": "Grid-connected Solar PV project in Kahone", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Solar - Centralized", "Methodology / Protocol": null, "Country": "Senegal", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "AERA Group", "Total Credits Issued": 114433, "Total Credits Retired": 32173, "issued_by_vintage": { "2021": 22456, "2022": 30140, "2023": 24727, "2024": 37110 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1683", "Project Name": "Kahone Solar PV Plant", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Solar - Centralized", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "Senegal", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "ENERGY RESOURCES SENEGAL SA", "Total Credits Issued": 129378, "Total Credits Retired": 63961, "issued_by_vintage": { "2018": 14393, "2019": 17642, "2020": 14716, "2021": 17210, "2022": 18642, "2023": 18773, "2024": 18316, "2025": 9686 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "Senegal / None / None", "value_b": "Senegal / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Solar - Centralized", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Solar - Centralized" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS10808 vs VCS VCS1683", "Name: Grid-connected Solar PV project in Kahone vs Kahone Solar PV Plant", "Developer: AERA Group vs ENERGY RESOURCES SENEGAL SA", "Credits issued by vintage: 2021:22456, 2022:30140, 2023:24727, 2024:37110 vs 2018:14393, 2019:17642, 2020:14716, 2021:17" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a Renewable Energy / Solar - Centralized project located in Senegal.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x8372778bba1f8390056bf45ea9f206c7172ce03617eaf4e35f35098d358baef2", "proof": [ "0x5e7278fee5b55e6cb61e29ba5fc96b7f7e74cc325b1653113c81b0b1e1baa200", "0x868265bac7ac59bb52658de00e92d25c66d4aa262aee8f4c6abfa13fe588fe70", "0xe7aa491e5c9116fcddc5057e199b9ffd7a609a810c28ed2f083f9518d8ba5abc", "0xa76977f2ee085b4f14ec73524d3446ee9177c3ecccf555d5912ac2f1f876932d", "0xd09064513da286d60121806e5b4afbc8a78acb525f8e2412451279c6808a1884", "0x5b9ccb750fb45c8ba42f45af2592f5656edc8e56e2aca0608a56c935d485b546" ] }, { "id": "GS513~VCS135", "a": "GS513", "b": "VCS135", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "China", "screen_score": 0.5048, "name_sim": 0.6451, "overlap_vintages": [ 2008 ], "overlap_volume": 70908, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS513", "Project Name": "Hebei Shangyi Manjing West Wind Farm VER Project", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "China", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Carbon Resource Management Ltd.", "Total Credits Issued": 74562, "Total Credits Retired": 74562, "issued_by_vintage": { "2008": 74562 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS135", "Project Name": "Shangyi Manjing Windfarm Project", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Late to verify", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "China", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Guohua (Hebei) Renewable Energy Co Ltd.", "Total Credits Issued": 184738, "Total Credits Retired": 177327, "issued_by_vintage": { "2008": 70908, "2009": 80992, "2010": 32838 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "China / None / None", "value_b": "China / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "value_b": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS513 vs VCS VCS135", "Name: Hebei Shangyi Manjing West Wind Farm VER Project vs Shangyi Manjing Windfarm Project", "Developer: Carbon Resource Management Ltd. vs Guohua (Hebei) Renewable Energy Co Ltd.", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Late to verify" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a Renewable Energy / Wind project in China using Methodology ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x722b7bd7cc9145844dbf2a39e0350ca404caef33e4275940901b34863df6078a", "proof": [ "0x51d473bf70f7564b506262a37606ab9bcdfabaf142663ec6fc93dcd37f9ef3e0", "0xe7e129b951d390f4dc3f764d54ba1fd4224e5053c631d96a86aea618da54b811", "0x559363f150dace2ae41803adfe57d6530795ccb60f9c7583fb2439bd295923d5", "0xa76977f2ee085b4f14ec73524d3446ee9177c3ecccf555d5912ac2f1f876932d", "0xd09064513da286d60121806e5b4afbc8a78acb525f8e2412451279c6808a1884", "0x5b9ccb750fb45c8ba42f45af2592f5656edc8e56e2aca0608a56c935d485b546" ] }, { "id": "GS3015~VCS900", "a": "GS3015", "b": "VCS900", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "Viet Nam", "screen_score": 0.7, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [ 2014 ], "overlap_volume": 53186, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS3015", "Project Name": "Za Hung Hydropower Project", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Hydropower", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "Viet Nam", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Vietnam Carbon Assets Ltd.", "Total Credits Issued": 819090, "Total Credits Retired": 89422, "issued_by_vintage": { "2013": 73544, "2014": 63791, "2015": 60792, "2016": 69031, "2017": 97114, "2018": 51435, "2019": 69140, "2020": 105947, "2021": 111837, "2022": 116459 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS900", "Project Name": "Za Hung Hydropower Project", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Late to verify", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Hydropower", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "Viet Nam", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Za Hung Joint Stock Company", "Total Credits Issued": 204517, "Total Credits Retired": 204417, "issued_by_vintage": { "2010": 79885, "2011": 71446, "2014": 53186 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Za Hung Hydropower Project", "value_b": "Za Hung Hydropower Project" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "Viet Nam / None / None", "value_b": "Viet Nam / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Hydropower", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Hydropower" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "value_b": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS3015 vs VCS VCS900", "Developer: Vietnam Carbon Assets Ltd. vs Za Hung Joint Stock Company", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Late to verify", "Credits issued by vintage: 2013-2022 vs 2010-2014" ], "reason": "Both listings describe the Za Hung Hydropower Project in Viet Nam using the ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources methodology.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x51d473bf70f7564b506262a37606ab9bcdfabaf142663ec6fc93dcd37f9ef3e0", "proof": [ "0x722b7bd7cc9145844dbf2a39e0350ca404caef33e4275940901b34863df6078a", "0xe7e129b951d390f4dc3f764d54ba1fd4224e5053c631d96a86aea618da54b811", "0x559363f150dace2ae41803adfe57d6530795ccb60f9c7583fb2439bd295923d5", "0xa76977f2ee085b4f14ec73524d3446ee9177c3ecccf555d5912ac2f1f876932d", "0xd09064513da286d60121806e5b4afbc8a78acb525f8e2412451279c6808a1884", "0x5b9ccb750fb45c8ba42f45af2592f5656edc8e56e2aca0608a56c935d485b546" ] }, { "id": "CAR400~VCS1528", "a": "CAR400", "b": "VCS1528", "registry_a": "CAR", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.5629, "name_sim": 0.7507, "overlap_vintages": [ 2014 ], "overlap_volume": 45730, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "CAR400", "Project Name": "South Jordan Landfill Gas Destruction Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Waste Management", "Type": "Landfill Methane", "Methodology / Protocol": "CAR U.S. Landfill Protocol", "Country": "United States", "State": "UTAH", "Project Site Location": "South Jordan", "Project Developer": "Anew Environmental, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 2053918, "Total Credits Retired": 1520514, "issued_by_vintage": { "2009": 38622, "2010": 92414, "2011": 138699, "2012": 136521, "2013": 140053, "2014": 153858, "2015": 74626, "2018": 199888, "2019": 195962, "2020": 198757, "2021": 211183, "2022": 212352, "2023": 218257, "2024": 42726 }, "notes": "Project reached its NMOC threshold, moved project to completed. The project developer through v10 was Element Markets Emissions, LLC" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1528", "Project Name": "Granger South Jordan Landfill Gas Destruction Project - CER Conversion", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Units Transferred from Approved GHG Program", "Scope": "Waste Management", "Type": "Landfill Methane", "Methodology / Protocol": "CAR U.S. Landfill Protocol", "Country": "United States", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Total Credits Issued": 45730, "Total Credits Retired": 45730, "issued_by_vintage": { "2014": 45730 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Waste Management / Landfill Methane", "value_b": "Waste Management / Landfill Methane" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "CAR U.S. Landfill Protocol", "value_b": "CAR U.S. Landfill Protocol" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: CAR CAR400 vs VCS VCS1528", "Name: South Jordan Landfill Gas Destruction Project vs Granger South Jordan Landfill Gas Destruction Project - CERBER", "Developer: Anew Environmental, LLC vs Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Status: Completed vs Units Transferred from Approved GHG Program" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a Waste Management / Landfill Methane project using the CAR U.S. Landfill Protocol.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xcbcc783cc07a2d60a61f6ce63a5e11f16fe08dec59645a8bb81f44a2648affc9", "proof": [ "0xcdd7afc570a6e408c4e7629e9acad8f82dede28eb8cc1dfb6f309041c3030093", "0x534bebd5954135771702a69f8926acf36c649f3f27b8c5e0d0db815626c6f902", "0x559363f150dace2ae41803adfe57d6530795ccb60f9c7583fb2439bd295923d5", "0xa76977f2ee085b4f14ec73524d3446ee9177c3ecccf555d5912ac2f1f876932d", "0xd09064513da286d60121806e5b4afbc8a78acb525f8e2412451279c6808a1884", "0x5b9ccb750fb45c8ba42f45af2592f5656edc8e56e2aca0608a56c935d485b546" ] }, { "id": "GS1588~VCS1887", "a": "GS1588", "b": "VCS1887", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "China", "screen_score": 0.7, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [ 2014, 2016 ], "overlap_volume": 36248, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS1588", "Project Name": "Nanyang Danjiang River Solar Cooker Project Phase II", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.C. Thermal energy production with or without electricity", "Country": "China", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Sirreon Technology & Development (Beijing) Co.Ltd", "Total Credits Issued": 672665, "Total Credits Retired": 102115, "issued_by_vintage": { "2013": 86299, "2014": 71390, "2016": 67776, "2017": 88323, "2018": 88890, "2019": 76519, "2020": 71071, "2021": 62201, "2022": 60196 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1887", "Project Name": "Nanyang Danjiang River Solar Cooker Project Phase II", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Late to verify", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.C. Thermal energy production with or without electricity", "Country": "China", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Total Credits Issued": 137267, "Total Credits Retired": 137267, "issued_by_vintage": { "2014": 17171, "2015": 101019, "2016": 19077 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Nanyang Danjiang River Solar Cooker Project Phase II", "value_b": "Nanyang Danjiang River Solar Cooker Project Phase II" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "China / None / None", "value_b": "China / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "AMS-I.C. Thermal energy production with or without electricity", "value_b": "AMS-I.C. Thermal energy production with or without electricity" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS1588 vs VCS VCS1887", "Developer: Sirreon Technology & Development (Beijing) Co.Ltd vs Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Late to verify", "Credits issued by vintage: 2013:86299, 2014:71390, 2016:67776, 2017:88323, 2018:88890, 2019:76519, 2020:71071, 2021:6220" ], "reason": "Both listings describe the Nanyang Danjiang River Solar Cooker Project Phase II located in China under the Household & Community / Cookstoves scope using the AMS-I.C. Thermal energy production with or without electricity methodology.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xcdd7afc570a6e408c4e7629e9acad8f82dede28eb8cc1dfb6f309041c3030093", "proof": [ "0xcbcc783cc07a2d60a61f6ce63a5e11f16fe08dec59645a8bb81f44a2648affc9", "0x534bebd5954135771702a69f8926acf36c649f3f27b8c5e0d0db815626c6f902", "0x559363f150dace2ae41803adfe57d6530795ccb60f9c7583fb2439bd295923d5", "0xa76977f2ee085b4f14ec73524d3446ee9177c3ecccf555d5912ac2f1f876932d", "0xd09064513da286d60121806e5b4afbc8a78acb525f8e2412451279c6808a1884", "0x5b9ccb750fb45c8ba42f45af2592f5656edc8e56e2aca0608a56c935d485b546" ] }, { "id": "GS1378~VCS1886", "a": "GS1378", "b": "VCS1886", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "China", "screen_score": 0.7, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [ 2014, 2016 ], "overlap_volume": 30551, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS1378", "Project Name": "Nanyang Danjiang River Solar Cooker Project Phase I", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.C. Thermal energy production with or without electricity", "Country": "China", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Sirreon Technology & Development (Beijing) Co.Ltd", "Total Credits Issued": 532005, "Total Credits Retired": 50400, "issued_by_vintage": { "2013": 83174, "2014": 68224, "2016": 67116, "2017": 86216, "2018": 4800, "2019": 75807, "2020": 68747, "2021": 60715, "2022": 17206 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1886", "Project Name": "Nanyang Danjiang River Solar Cooker Project Phase I", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Late to verify", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.C. Thermal energy production with or without electricity", "Country": "China", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Total Credits Issued": 129914, "Total Credits Retired": 129914, "issued_by_vintage": { "2014": 10856, "2015": 99363, "2016": 19695 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Nanyang Danjiang River Solar Cooker Project Phase I", "value_b": "Nanyang Danjiang River Solar Cooker Project Phase I" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "China / None / None", "value_b": "China / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "AMS-I.C. Thermal energy production with or without electricity", "value_b": "AMS-I.C. Thermal energy production with or without electricity" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS1378 vs VCS VCS1886", "Developer: Sirreon Technology & Development (Beijing) Co.Ltd vs Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Late to verify", "Credits issued by vintage: 2013:83174, 2014:68224, 2016:67116, 2017:86216, 2018:4800, 2019:75807, 2020:68747, 2021:60715" ], "reason": "Both listings describe the Nanyang Danjiang River Solar Cooker Project Phase I located in China under the Household & Community / Cookstoves scope using the AMS-I.C. Thermal energy production with or without electricity methodology.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x95d0fe3608c8962fc0df7015e39a86db4b3e25ab83c56c5b2a31c6f15536487d", "proof": [ "0xb972d2c48357d3d031cee6dd09bf0398383e565d8ce069890fbe0961521cef39", "0x1d6f4c603ec539fb589e9869195be40575c3c4882232d861d8a726eda920f30b", "0x5d1662da1536766d6907d8d0d7055ee5ce7c3e3143f31c1ee0393828ea62a732", "0x046c6cc536053ff0bb4d6a3737166788973e41d57e378043cfd4a804e55d2821", "0xd09064513da286d60121806e5b4afbc8a78acb525f8e2412451279c6808a1884", "0x5b9ccb750fb45c8ba42f45af2592f5656edc8e56e2aca0608a56c935d485b546" ] }, { "id": "CAR495~VCS80", "a": "CAR495", "b": "VCS80", "registry_a": "CAR", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.7, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [ 2009 ], "overlap_volume": 25180, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "CAR495", "Project Name": "Greenville County Landfill Gas Utilization Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Waste Management", "Type": "Landfill Methane", "Methodology / Protocol": "CAR U.S. Landfill Protocol", "Country": "United States", "State": "SOUTH CAROLINA", "Project Site Location": "Greenville County; Greer", "Project Developer": "Anew Environmental, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 939240, "Total Credits Retired": 642866, "issued_by_vintage": { "2009": 83458, "2010": 96497, "2011": 94957, "2012": 83662, "2013": 75303, "2014": 73231, "2015": 74718, "2016": 84168, "2017": 44758, "2018": 18200, "2019": 47319, "2020": 48407, "2021": 58992, "2022": 33881, "2023": 12689, "2024": 9000 }, "notes": "Project developer in v1 was Greenville Gas Producers, LLC and The project Developer through v10 was Element Markets Emissions, LLC" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS80", "Project Name": "Greenville County Landfill Gas Utilization Project", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Late to verify", "Scope": "Waste Management", "Type": "Landfill Methane", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0001 Flaring or use of landfill gas", "Country": "United States", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Greenville Gas Producers, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 151922, "Total Credits Retired": 142154, "issued_by_vintage": { "2007": 24357, "2008": 102385, "2009": 25180 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Greenville County Landfill Gas Utilization Project", "value_b": "Greenville County Landfill Gas Utilization Project" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Waste Management / Landfill Methane", "value_b": "Waste Management / Landfill Methane" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: CAR CAR495 vs VCS VCS80", "Developer: Anew Environmental, LLC vs Greenville Gas Producers, LLC", "Methodology: CAR U.S. Landfill Protocol vs ACM0001 Flaring or use of landfill gas", "Status: Registered vs Late to verify" ], "reason": "Both listings describe the Greenville County Landfill Gas Utilization Project under the Scope / Type of Waste Management / Landfill Methane.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xb972d2c48357d3d031cee6dd09bf0398383e565d8ce069890fbe0961521cef39", "proof": [ "0x95d0fe3608c8962fc0df7015e39a86db4b3e25ab83c56c5b2a31c6f15536487d", "0x1d6f4c603ec539fb589e9869195be40575c3c4882232d861d8a726eda920f30b", "0x5d1662da1536766d6907d8d0d7055ee5ce7c3e3143f31c1ee0393828ea62a732", "0x046c6cc536053ff0bb4d6a3737166788973e41d57e378043cfd4a804e55d2821", "0xd09064513da286d60121806e5b4afbc8a78acb525f8e2412451279c6808a1884", "0x5b9ccb750fb45c8ba42f45af2592f5656edc8e56e2aca0608a56c935d485b546" ] }, { "id": "GS7754~VCS924", "a": "GS7754", "b": "VCS924", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.7, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [ 2018 ], "overlap_volume": 19229, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS7754", "Project Name": "Tuppadahalli Wind Energy Project", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": null, "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Kosher Climate India Pvt Ltd.", "Total Credits Issued": 323794, "Total Credits Retired": 105716, "issued_by_vintage": { "2018": 50850, "2019": 116337, "2020": 107198, "2021": 49409 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS924", "Project Name": "Tuppadahalli Wind Energy Project", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Withdrawn", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Tuppadahalli Energy India Pvt. Ltd.", "Total Credits Issued": 798247, "Total Credits Retired": 798105, "issued_by_vintage": { "2012": 165964, "2013": 134330, "2014": 122000, "2015": 111670, "2016": 126066, "2017": 118988, "2018": 19229 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Tuppadahalli Wind Energy Project", "value_b": "Tuppadahalli Wind Energy Project" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS7754 vs VCS VCS924", "Developer: Kosher Climate India Pvt Ltd. vs Tuppadahalli Energy India Pvt. Ltd.", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Withdrawn", "Credits issued by vintage: 2018:50850, 2019:116337, 2020:107198, 2021:49409 vs 2012:165964, 2013:134330, 2014:122000, 20" ], "reason": "Both listings describe the Tuppadahalli Wind Energy Project located in India under the Scope / Type of Renewable Energy / Wind.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x3d6437520fa3c88c176c1f6743e7adfaa51fefdf810db83a7746338da9a306dd", "proof": [ "0x807fa5c364820a89cd231229c4cf8d525ab1f77fd81a5846604a28d29d61ff1f", "0x7fa3fe0efea12a87d7f0fee994cce78ff96065ead27aa003f1b7b0bbda9efc31", "0x5d1662da1536766d6907d8d0d7055ee5ce7c3e3143f31c1ee0393828ea62a732", "0x046c6cc536053ff0bb4d6a3737166788973e41d57e378043cfd4a804e55d2821", "0xd09064513da286d60121806e5b4afbc8a78acb525f8e2412451279c6808a1884", "0x5b9ccb750fb45c8ba42f45af2592f5656edc8e56e2aca0608a56c935d485b546" ] }, { "id": "GS4124~VCS1886", "a": "GS4124", "b": "VCS1886", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "China", "screen_score": 0.5546, "name_sim": 0.7357, "overlap_vintages": [ 2014 ], "overlap_volume": 10856, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS4124", "Project Name": "Nanyang Danjiang River Solar Cooker Project Phase I (GS1378 CER to VER conversion)", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.C. Thermal energy production with or without electricity", "Country": "China", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Sirreon Technology & Development (Beijing) Co.Ltd", "Total Credits Issued": 107412, "Total Credits Retired": 107412, "issued_by_vintage": { "2012": 61700, "2014": 45712 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1886", "Project Name": "Nanyang Danjiang River Solar Cooker Project Phase I", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Late to verify", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.C. Thermal energy production with or without electricity", "Country": "China", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Total Credits Issued": 129914, "Total Credits Retired": 129914, "issued_by_vintage": { "2014": 10856, "2015": 99363, "2016": 19695 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "China / None / None", "value_b": "China / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "AMS-I.C. Thermal energy production with or without electricity", "value_b": "AMS-I.C. Thermal energy production with or without electricity" }, { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Nanyang Danjiang River Solar Cooker Project Phase I (GS1378 CER to VER转换)", "value_b": "Nanyang Danjiang River Solar Cooker Project Phase I" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS4124 vs VCS VCS1886", "Developer: Sirreon Technology & Development (Beijing) Co.Ltd vs Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Late to verify", "Credits issued by vintage: 2012:61700, 2014:45712 vs 2014:10856, 2015:99363, 2016:19695" ], "reason": "Both listings describe the Nanyang Danjiang River Solar Cooker Project Phase I located in China under the Household & Community / Cookstoves scope using the AMS-I.C. Thermal energy production with or without electricity methodology.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x807fa5c364820a89cd231229c4cf8d525ab1f77fd81a5846604a28d29d61ff1f", "proof": [ "0x3d6437520fa3c88c176c1f6743e7adfaa51fefdf810db83a7746338da9a306dd", "0x7fa3fe0efea12a87d7f0fee994cce78ff96065ead27aa003f1b7b0bbda9efc31", "0x5d1662da1536766d6907d8d0d7055ee5ce7c3e3143f31c1ee0393828ea62a732", "0x046c6cc536053ff0bb4d6a3737166788973e41d57e378043cfd4a804e55d2821", "0xd09064513da286d60121806e5b4afbc8a78acb525f8e2412451279c6808a1884", "0x5b9ccb750fb45c8ba42f45af2592f5656edc8e56e2aca0608a56c935d485b546" ] }, { "id": "GS1371~VCS783", "a": "GS1371", "b": "VCS783", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "Thailand", "screen_score": 0.7, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [ 2014 ], "overlap_volume": 10000, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS1371", "Project Name": "Bangkok Kamphaeng Saen East: Landfill Gas to Electricity Project", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Waste Management", "Type": "Landfill Methane", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0001 Flaring or use of landfill gas", "Country": "Thailand", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Sindicatum Carbon Capital International Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 903086, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2012": 246904, "2013": 350762, "2014": 305420 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS783", "Project Name": "Bangkok Kamphaeng Saen East: Landfill Gas to Electricity Project", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Withdrawn", "Scope": "Waste Management", "Type": "Landfill Methane", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0001 Flaring or use of landfill gas", "Country": "Thailand", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Bangkok Green Power Co., Ltd.", "Total Credits Issued": 146381, "Total Credits Retired": 100500, "issued_by_vintage": { "2011": 136381, "2014": 10000 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Bangkok Kamphaeng Saen East: Landfill Gas to Electricity Project", "value_b": "Bangkok Kamphaeng Saen East: Landfill Gas to Electricity Project" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "Thailand / None / None", "value_b": "Thailand / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Waste Management / Landfill Methane", "value_b": "Waste Management / Landfill Methane" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ACM0001 Flaring or use of landfill gas", "value_b": "ACM0001 Flaring or use of landfill gas" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS1371 vs VCS VCS783", "Developer: Sindicatum Carbon Capital International Limited vs Bangkok Green Power Co., Ltd.", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Withdrawn", "Credits issued by vintage: 2012:246904, 2013:350762, 2014:305420 vs 2011:136381, 2014:10000" ], "reason": "Both listings describe the Bangkok Kamphaeng Saen East: Landfill Gas to Electricity Project in Thailand using the ACM0001 Flaring or use of landfill gas methodology for Waste Management / Landfill Methane.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x859abd8e655e1efb27642b5002095df89bbdf24316f4ecfd448f66fce1681393", "proof": [ "0x8138d10bfec5651be2d1eeee5a50251bbfb2412b4840ece8a1d50ca634553ef1", "0xea1dbef1449495f8335210fd8b7b8a7cc9db472791b2d270ef8574f6c9419d68", "0xaf6229c37e9cb782d5cbea4a0bfdb329adc1842451e9279b9ad7c92251c5fdc8", "0x046c6cc536053ff0bb4d6a3737166788973e41d57e378043cfd4a804e55d2821", "0xd09064513da286d60121806e5b4afbc8a78acb525f8e2412451279c6808a1884", "0x5b9ccb750fb45c8ba42f45af2592f5656edc8e56e2aca0608a56c935d485b546" ] }, { "id": "GS5064~VCS1692", "a": "GS5064", "b": "VCS1692", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.7, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [ 2017 ], "overlap_volume": 8687, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS5064", "Project Name": "15 MW Wind Power Project by RSPL Ltd (EKIESL-CDM-May-16-04)", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "EKI Energy Services Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 58004, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 16938, "2018": 28775, "2019": 12291 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1692", "Project Name": "15 MW Wind Power Project by RSPL Ltd (EKIESL-CDM-May-16-04)", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Withdrawn", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "RSPL Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 30887, "Total Credits Retired": 30887, "issued_by_vintage": { "2015": 61, "2016": 22139, "2017": 8687 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "15 MW Wind Power Project by RSPL Ltd (EKIESL-CDM-May-16-04)", "value_b": "15 MW Wind Power Project by RSPL Ltd (EKIESL-CDM-May-16-04)" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation", "value_b": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS5064 vs VCS VCS1692", "Developer: EKI Energy Services Limited vs RSPL Limited", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Withdrawn", "Credits issued by vintage: 2017:16938, 2018:28775, 2019:12291 vs 2015:61, 2016:22139, 2017:8687" ], "reason": "Both listings share the same project name, country, scope, and methodology.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x8138d10bfec5651be2d1eeee5a50251bbfb2412b4840ece8a1d50ca634553ef1", "proof": [ "0x859abd8e655e1efb27642b5002095df89bbdf24316f4ecfd448f66fce1681393", "0xea1dbef1449495f8335210fd8b7b8a7cc9db472791b2d270ef8574f6c9419d68", "0xaf6229c37e9cb782d5cbea4a0bfdb329adc1842451e9279b9ad7c92251c5fdc8", "0x046c6cc536053ff0bb4d6a3737166788973e41d57e378043cfd4a804e55d2821", "0xd09064513da286d60121806e5b4afbc8a78acb525f8e2412451279c6808a1884", "0x5b9ccb750fb45c8ba42f45af2592f5656edc8e56e2aca0608a56c935d485b546" ] }, { "id": "GS2405~VCS370", "a": "GS2405", "b": "VCS370", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.9, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [ 2013, 2017 ], "overlap_volume": 7619, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS2405", "Project Name": "GRID CONNECTED BUNDLED WIND POWER PROJECT IN GUJARAT MANAGED BY ENERCON (INDIA) LIMITED", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Wind World (India) Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 95393, "Total Credits Retired": 95353, "issued_by_vintage": { "2013": 18585, "2014": 22867, "2015": 26776, "2016": 25125, "2017": 2040 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS370", "Project Name": "Grid connected bundled wind power project in Gujarat managed by Enercon (India) Limited", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Wind World (India) Ltd.", "Total Credits Issued": 240584, "Total Credits Retired": 238987, "issued_by_vintage": { "2008": 24194, "2009": 26003, "2010": 24109, "2011": 23940, "2012": 24978, "2013": 5579, "2017": 21085, "2018": 23270, "2019": 23973, "2020": 19654, "2021": 23799 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Wind World (India) Limited", "value_b": "Wind World (India) Ltd." }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "value_b": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources" }, { "field": "Name", "value_a": "GRID CONNECTED BUNDLED WIND POWER PROJECT IN GUJARAT MANAGED BY ENERCON (INDIA)舞", "value_b": "Grid connected bundled wind power project in Gujarat managed by Enercon (India)舞" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS2405 vs VCS VCS370", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Registered", "Credits issued by vintage: 2013:18585, 2014:22867, 2015:26776, 2016:25125, 2017:2040 vs 2008:24194, 2009:26003, 2010:241" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a Renewable Energy / Wind project in India developed by Wind World (India) Limited using methodology ACM0002.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xb302eb7580d39de263042b18660b8a39b124f2e3c2cb885a093f9e3d47228965", "proof": [ "0xf4387d63f837a2ab93cbaf9b83b05db89dbc714f4539b71b901ffc633adcec43", "0x806cb9ad2d46e7ab8b6213d547b0e75c66d7c736827271840749fc61094a5a49", "0xaf6229c37e9cb782d5cbea4a0bfdb329adc1842451e9279b9ad7c92251c5fdc8", "0x046c6cc536053ff0bb4d6a3737166788973e41d57e378043cfd4a804e55d2821", "0xd09064513da286d60121806e5b4afbc8a78acb525f8e2412451279c6808a1884", "0x5b9ccb750fb45c8ba42f45af2592f5656edc8e56e2aca0608a56c935d485b546" ] }, { "id": "CAR498~VCS1527", "a": "CAR498", "b": "VCS1527", "registry_a": "CAR", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.5805, "name_sim": 0.7464, "overlap_vintages": [ 2014 ], "overlap_volume": 4270, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "CAR498", "Project Name": "Wolf Creek Landfill", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Waste Management", "Type": "Landfill Methane", "Methodology / Protocol": "CAR U.S. Landfill Protocol", "Country": "United States", "State": "GEORGIA", "Project Site Location": "Twiggs County, Dry Branch", "Project Developer": "Sustainable Energy Solutions LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 1165003, "Total Credits Retired": 888840, "issued_by_vintage": { "2010": 78927, "2011": 91196, "2012": 109593, "2013": 127349, "2014": 109562, "2015": 118625, "2016": 104749, "2017": 169274, "2018": 137746, "2019": 117982 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1527", "Project Name": "Wolf Creek Landfill - CER Conversion", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Units Transferred from Approved GHG Program", "Scope": "Waste Management", "Type": "Landfill Methane", "Methodology / Protocol": "CAR U.S. Landfill Protocol", "Country": "United States", "State": "GEORGIA", "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Total Credits Issued": 4270, "Total Credits Retired": 4270, "issued_by_vintage": { "2014": 4270 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Wolf Creek Landfill", "value_b": "Wolf Creek Landfill - CER Conversion" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / GEORGIA / Twiggs County, Dry Branch", "value_b": "United States / GEORGIA / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Waste Management / Landfill Methane", "value_b": "Waste Management / Landfill Methane" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "CAR U.S. Landfill Protocol", "value_b": "CAR U.S. Landfill Protocol" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: CAR CAR498 vs VCS VCS1527", "Developer: Sustainable Energy Solutions LLC vs Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Status: Completed vs Units Transferred from Approved GHG Program", "Credits issued by vintage: 2010-2019 list vs 2014:4270" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a Waste Management / Landfill Methane project using the CAR U.S. Landfill Protocol located in United States / GEORGIA.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xf4387d63f837a2ab93cbaf9b83b05db89dbc714f4539b71b901ffc633adcec43", "proof": [ "0xb302eb7580d39de263042b18660b8a39b124f2e3c2cb885a093f9e3d47228965", "0x806cb9ad2d46e7ab8b6213d547b0e75c66d7c736827271840749fc61094a5a49", "0xaf6229c37e9cb782d5cbea4a0bfdb329adc1842451e9279b9ad7c92251c5fdc8", "0x046c6cc536053ff0bb4d6a3737166788973e41d57e378043cfd4a804e55d2821", "0xd09064513da286d60121806e5b4afbc8a78acb525f8e2412451279c6808a1884", "0x5b9ccb750fb45c8ba42f45af2592f5656edc8e56e2aca0608a56c935d485b546" ] }, { "id": "GS6051~VCS1879", "a": "GS6051", "b": "VCS1879", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "Sri Lanka", "screen_score": 0.6194, "name_sim": 0.8534, "overlap_vintages": [ 2016 ], "overlap_volume": 1228, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS6051", "Project Name": "Adavikanda Kuruwita Division Mini Hydro Power Project", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Hydropower", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation", "Country": "Sri Lanka", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Alternate Power Systems (Pvt) Ltd", "Total Credits Issued": 14802, "Total Credits Retired": 7401, "issued_by_vintage": { "2016": 1228, "2017": 13574 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1879", "Project Name": "Adavikanda, Kuruwita Division Mini Hydro Power Project - CER Conversion", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Units Transferred from Approved GHG Program", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Hydropower", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation", "Country": "Sri Lanka", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Total Credits Issued": 20000, "Total Credits Retired": 19995, "issued_by_vintage": { "2016": 20000 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "Sri Lanka / None / None", "value_b": "Sri Lanka / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Hydropower", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Hydropower" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation", "value_b": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation" }, { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Adavikanda Kuruwita Division Mini Hydro Power Project", "value_b": "Adavikanda, Kuruwita Division Mini Hydro Power Project - CER Conversion" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS6051 vs VCS VCS1879", "Developer: Alternate Power Systems (Pvt) Ltd vs Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Units Transferred from Approved GHG Program", "Credits issued by vintage: 2016:1228, 2017:13574 vs 2016:20000" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a Renewable Energy / Hydropower project in Sri Lanka using the AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation methodology.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x66afab47ccd6ce7de208814072d4dadb977c051638b11c9d975b8a8346286e8d", "proof": [ "0x576f5fe588548942033c3e31f2fe69ce644e3a1031f051c4ac2f2a022b0fb434", "0x42a60a758d0cd6af301f68a3de704ef2bc77cc81b1a6f7f6d6c691c453936d8f", "0x5aff1e9f34bb4ad266f111684189579ebff6f22b0f18fbb32eefdf5e5e057a81", "0x2161bf4b3394e4f423e1bd8bf659c88a76b48bd430c3ad04a9bf87b4ff7eed69", "0xa701f5d9cc00fa91a8ee09aab687e0a1cf0cd4997188d40a2afe672883a694cc", "0x5b9ccb750fb45c8ba42f45af2592f5656edc8e56e2aca0608a56c935d485b546" ] }, { "id": "GS452~VCS1703", "a": "GS452", "b": "VCS1703", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "China", "screen_score": 0.6478, "name_sim": 0.905, "overlap_vintages": [ 2010 ], "overlap_volume": 722, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS452", "Project Name": "*Huadian Ningxia Ningdong Yangjiayao 45MW Wind-farm Project", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "China", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Climate Impact Partners Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 182783, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2008": 52106, "2009": 82097, "2010": 48580 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1703", "Project Name": "Huadian Ningxia Ningdong Yangjiayao 45MW Wind-farm Project - CER Conversion", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Units Transferred from Approved GHG Program", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "China", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Total Credits Issued": 722, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2010": 722 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Huadian Ningxia Ningdong Yangjiayao 45MW Wind-farm Project", "value_b": "Huadian Ningxia Ningdong Yangjiayao 45MW Wind-farm Project - CER Conversion" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "China / None / None", "value_b": "China / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "value_b": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS452 vs VCS VCS1703", "Developer: Climate Impact Partners Limited vs Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Units Transferred from Approved GHG Program", "Credits issued by vintage: 2008:52106, 2009:82097, 2010:48580 vs 2010:722" ], "reason": "Both listings describe the Huadian Ningxia Ningdong Yangjiayao 45MW Wind-farm Project located in China using Methodology ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x576f5fe588548942033c3e31f2fe69ce644e3a1031f051c4ac2f2a022b0fb434", "proof": [ "0x66afab47ccd6ce7de208814072d4dadb977c051638b11c9d975b8a8346286e8d", "0x42a60a758d0cd6af301f68a3de704ef2bc77cc81b1a6f7f6d6c691c453936d8f", "0x5aff1e9f34bb4ad266f111684189579ebff6f22b0f18fbb32eefdf5e5e057a81", "0x2161bf4b3394e4f423e1bd8bf659c88a76b48bd430c3ad04a9bf87b4ff7eed69", "0xa701f5d9cc00fa91a8ee09aab687e0a1cf0cd4997188d40a2afe672883a694cc", "0x5b9ccb750fb45c8ba42f45af2592f5656edc8e56e2aca0608a56c935d485b546" ] }, { "id": "ACR0258~CAR992", "a": "ACR0258", "b": "CAR992", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 1, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0258", "Project Name": "EOS ARB ODS 2013-1", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "Country": "United States", "State": "ARKANSAS", "Project Site Location": "El Dorado", "Project Developer": "EOS Climate Inc", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR992", "Project Name": "EOS ARB ODS 2013-1", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "Country": "United States", "State": "ARKANSAS", "Project Site Location": "El Dorado", "Project Developer": "EOS Climate Inc.", "Total Credits Issued": 107542, "Total Credits Retired": 107542, "issued_by_vintage": { "2013": 107542 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "EOS ARB ODS 2013-1", "value_b": "EOS ARB ODS 2013-1" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "EOS Climate Inc", "value_b": "EOS Climate Inc." }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / ARKANSAS / El Dorado", "value_b": "United States / ARKANSAS / El Dorado" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "value_b": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances起こ", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances起こ" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR0258 vs CAR CAR992", "Credits issued by vintage: none vs 2013:107542", "Description: [Present in A, Missing in B]" ], "reason": "Both listings share the same Name, Developer, Country / State / Site, Scope / Type, and Methodology.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x21cc7818e9a7e6754035edddb8f8b8710aa82a4e9a6ad3886cf9ded3e5a7a56a", "proof": [ "0x9ac390b96bf40c84bdda2e89ab2499c4853ea8365d56a686a9e88acd4d2fc855", "0x686ab401b446b6fad97497be4cd93bfb3c9eb4f6ac082875600daaf38f696abe", "0x5aff1e9f34bb4ad266f111684189579ebff6f22b0f18fbb32eefdf5e5e057a81", "0x2161bf4b3394e4f423e1bd8bf659c88a76b48bd430c3ad04a9bf87b4ff7eed69", "0xa701f5d9cc00fa91a8ee09aab687e0a1cf0cd4997188d40a2afe672883a694cc", "0x5b9ccb750fb45c8ba42f45af2592f5656edc8e56e2aca0608a56c935d485b546" ] }, { "id": "ACR0542~CAR2090", "a": "ACR0542", "b": "CAR2090", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 1, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0542", "Project Name": "Orient 6 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Waltonville", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 85622, "Total Credits Retired": 56219, "issued_by_vintage": { "2020": 10532, "2021": 12745, "2022": 19398, "2023": 26817, "2024": 16130 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2090", "Project Name": "Orient 6 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Waltonville", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment,LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 29696, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 29696 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Orient 6 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "value_b": "Orient 6 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Environment,LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / ILLINOIS / Waltonville", "value_b": "United States / ILLINOIS / Waltonville" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR0542 vs CAR CAR2090", "Status: Transferred ARB Project vs Registered", "Credits issued by vintage: 2020:10532, 2021:12745, 2022:19398, 2023:26817, 2024:16130 vs 2025:29696" ], "reason": "Both listings describe the Orient 6 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project in Waltonville, Illinois, developed by Keyrock Environment LLC using the ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x9ac390b96bf40c84bdda2e89ab2499c4853ea8365d56a686a9e88acd4d2fc855", "proof": [ "0x21cc7818e9a7e6754035edddb8f8b8710aa82a4e9a6ad3886cf9ded3e5a7a56a", "0x686ab401b446b6fad97497be4cd93bfb3c9eb4f6ac082875600daaf38f696abe", "0x5aff1e9f34bb4ad266f111684189579ebff6f22b0f18fbb32eefdf5e5e057a81", "0x2161bf4b3394e4f423e1bd8bf659c88a76b48bd430c3ad04a9bf87b4ff7eed69", "0xa701f5d9cc00fa91a8ee09aab687e0a1cf0cd4997188d40a2afe672883a694cc", "0x5b9ccb750fb45c8ba42f45af2592f5656edc8e56e2aca0608a56c935d485b546" ] }, { "id": "ACR0546~CAR2089", "a": "ACR0546", "b": "CAR2089", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 1, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0546", "Project Name": "Middle Fork Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Benton", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 78936, "Total Credits Retired": 40944, "issued_by_vintage": { "2020": 10640, "2021": 8285, "2022": 16484, "2023": 18875, "2024": 24652 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2089", "Project Name": "Middle Fork Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Benton", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment,LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 27227, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 27227 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Middle Fork Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "value_b": "Middle Fork Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / ILLINOIS / Benton", "value_b": "United States / ILLINOIS / Benton" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Environment,LLC" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR0546 vs CAR CAR2089", "Status: Transferred ARB Project vs Registered", "Credits issued by vintage: 2020-2024 vs 2025", "Description: Abandoned mine methane capture and on-site incineration vs [Missing]" ], "reason": "Both listings describe the Middle Fork Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project in Benton, Illinois, using the ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x61bb9033e120d9204ca78d992d7222f9f2507ada97a15bd7ae909c95bf5159a8", "proof": [ "0x8d6370fe8794732696023b871bafba70733058649fa0f047f6385be0053cda07", "0x666f039417bac99c4d420a501dc0928859882946b880f510582927bb2b7d61eb", "0x9135a9dc0daee467fcd6f6623c7089daaa7429b35c0610e84120154507098012", "0x2161bf4b3394e4f423e1bd8bf659c88a76b48bd430c3ad04a9bf87b4ff7eed69", "0xa701f5d9cc00fa91a8ee09aab687e0a1cf0cd4997188d40a2afe672883a694cc", "0x5b9ccb750fb45c8ba42f45af2592f5656edc8e56e2aca0608a56c935d485b546" ] }, { "id": "ACR0560~CAR2054", "a": "ACR0560", "b": "CAR2054", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 1, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0560", "Project Name": "Mine 84 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "PENNSYLVANIA", "Project Site Location": "Bethlehem Township", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 410590, "Total Credits Retired": 169308, "issued_by_vintage": { "2021": 70251, "2022": 103750, "2023": 113598, "2024": 122991 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2054", "Project Name": "Mine 84 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "PENNSYLVANIA", "Project Site Location": "Bethlehem Township", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment,LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 183994, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 183994 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Mine 84 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "value_b": "Mine 84 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / PENNSYLVANIA / Bethlehem Township", "value_b": "United States / PENNSYLVANIA / Bethlehem Township" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Environment,LLC" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR0560 vs CAR CAR2054", "Status: Transferred ARB Project vs Registered", "Credits issued by vintage: 2021:70251, 2022:103750, 2023:113598, 2024:122991 vs 2025:183994" ], "reason": "Both listings describe the Mine 84 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project in Bethlehem Township, Pennsylvania, using the ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x8d6370fe8794732696023b871bafba70733058649fa0f047f6385be0053cda07", "proof": [ "0x61bb9033e120d9204ca78d992d7222f9f2507ada97a15bd7ae909c95bf5159a8", "0x666f039417bac99c4d420a501dc0928859882946b880f510582927bb2b7d61eb", "0x9135a9dc0daee467fcd6f6623c7089daaa7429b35c0610e84120154507098012", "0x2161bf4b3394e4f423e1bd8bf659c88a76b48bd430c3ad04a9bf87b4ff7eed69", "0xa701f5d9cc00fa91a8ee09aab687e0a1cf0cd4997188d40a2afe672883a694cc", "0x5b9ccb750fb45c8ba42f45af2592f5656edc8e56e2aca0608a56c935d485b546" ] }, { "id": "ACR0578~CAR2092", "a": "ACR0578", "b": "CAR2092", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 1, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0578", "Project Name": "New Era Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Galatia", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 461227, "Total Credits Retired": 82012, "issued_by_vintage": { "2021": 94880, "2022": 77171, "2023": 68914, "2024": 220262 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2092", "Project Name": "New Era Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Galatia", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment,LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 220149, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 220149 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "New Era Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "value_b": "New Era Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / ILLINOIS / Galatia", "value_b": "United States / ILLINOIS / Galatia" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Environment,LLC" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR0578 vs CAR CAR2092", "Status: Transferred ARB Project vs Registered", "Credits issued by vintage: 2021:94880, 2022:77171, 2023:68914, 2024:220262 vs 2025:220149" ], "reason": "Both listings describe the New Era Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project in Galatia, Illinois, developed by Keyrock Environment LLC using the ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xaa20a50b154ae9be3cd49784dd4b5a6e00a7d91e70bdba1ba80806776a784055", "proof": [ "0xb47e56982866ea6003d7ca43fca60feb9827f8432e244863bfb7d65cfd2c042d", "0x4ed5ffb9b1f5cf636083a97410fc49e21a9e0cd7fc1587679ef80220dbc249b9", "0x9135a9dc0daee467fcd6f6623c7089daaa7429b35c0610e84120154507098012", "0x2161bf4b3394e4f423e1bd8bf659c88a76b48bd430c3ad04a9bf87b4ff7eed69", "0xa701f5d9cc00fa91a8ee09aab687e0a1cf0cd4997188d40a2afe672883a694cc", "0x5b9ccb750fb45c8ba42f45af2592f5656edc8e56e2aca0608a56c935d485b546" ] }, { "id": "ACR0669~CAR2113", "a": "ACR0669", "b": "CAR2113", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 1, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0669", "Project Name": "New Future Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Galatia", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 174700, "Total Credits Retired": 112158, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 62598, "2023": 49560, "2024": 62542 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2113", "Project Name": "New Future Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Galatia", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment,LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 73186, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 73186 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "New Future Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "value_b": "New Future Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / ILLINOIS / Galatia", "value_b": "United States / ILLINOIS / Galatia" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Environment,LLC" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR0669 vs CAR CAR2113", "Status: Transferred ARB Project vs Registered", "Credits issued by vintage: 2022:62598, 2023:49560, 2024:62542 vs 2025:73186" ], "reason": "Both listings describe the New Future Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project in Galatia, Illinois, developed by Keyrock Environment LLC using the ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xb47e56982866ea6003d7ca43fca60feb9827f8432e244863bfb7d65cfd2c042d", "proof": [ "0xaa20a50b154ae9be3cd49784dd4b5a6e00a7d91e70bdba1ba80806776a784055", "0x4ed5ffb9b1f5cf636083a97410fc49e21a9e0cd7fc1587679ef80220dbc249b9", "0x9135a9dc0daee467fcd6f6623c7089daaa7429b35c0610e84120154507098012", "0x2161bf4b3394e4f423e1bd8bf659c88a76b48bd430c3ad04a9bf87b4ff7eed69", "0xa701f5d9cc00fa91a8ee09aab687e0a1cf0cd4997188d40a2afe672883a694cc", "0x5b9ccb750fb45c8ba42f45af2592f5656edc8e56e2aca0608a56c935d485b546" ] }, { "id": "ACR0694~CAR2218", "a": "ACR0694", "b": "CAR2218", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 1, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0694", "Project Name": "Oaktown Fuel 1 Mine Methane Incineration Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "INDIANA", "Project Site Location": "Oaktown", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Energy LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 50238, "Total Credits Retired": 24947, "issued_by_vintage": { "2021": 14188, "2022": 14745, "2023": 10202, "2024": 11103 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2218", "Project Name": "Oaktown Fuel 1 Mine Methane Incineration Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "INDIANA", "Project Site Location": "Oaktown, IN", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Energy, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 11452, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 11452 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Oaktown Fuel 1 Mine Methane Incineration Project", "value_b": "Oaktown Fuel 1 Mine Methane Incineration Project" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Energy LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Energy, LLC" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" }, { "field": "Country / State", "value_a": "United States / INDIANA", "value_b": "United States / INDIANA" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR0694 vs CAR CAR2218", "Status: Transferred ARB Project vs Registered", "Site: Oaktown vs Oaktown, IN", "Credits issued by vintage: 2021-2024 vs 2025" ], "reason": "Both listings describe the Oaktown Fuel 1 Mine Methane Incineration Project developed by Keyrock Energy LLC using the ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x35a36cd2dcd472ede1aebf730203ea2cd4ad0ceb27cb20d4836c93a14995b797", "proof": [ "0xf0482e1229cb8baab00d6abe997619465ec8b5efbb38fa1988b1b6b3163ffef2", "0x34e7acba7cd2913941c4fe01456f7bb8943cdc591e270215d72a209736522262", "0x09f1deadfd2bd3a8e247bcf836668dbdf4f7d7ba17dea5a5154ddef5a1cd5655", "0x52dac7098829a719e43568be6a3780ceee65e64e74f2141248c25159df8e56d0", "0xa701f5d9cc00fa91a8ee09aab687e0a1cf0cd4997188d40a2afe672883a694cc", "0x5b9ccb750fb45c8ba42f45af2592f5656edc8e56e2aca0608a56c935d485b546" ] }, { "id": "ACR0746~CAR2057", "a": "ACR0746", "b": "CAR2057", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 1, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0746", "Project Name": "Beckley Pocahontas Mine Methane Incineration Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "WEST VIRGINIA", "Project Site Location": "Beckley", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Energy LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 163668, "Total Credits Retired": 43770, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 42364, "2023": 77370, "2025": 43934 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2057", "Project Name": "Beckley Pocahontas Mine Methane Incineration Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "WEST VIRGINIA", "Project Site Location": "Beckley", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Energy, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 67365, "Total Credits Retired": 23041, "issued_by_vintage": { "2024": 67365 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Beckley Pocahontas Mine Methane Incineration Project", "value_b": "Beckley Pocahontas Mine Methane Incineration Project" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / WEST VIRGINIA / Beckley", "value_b": "United States / WEST VIRGINIA / Beckley" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Energy LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Energy, LLC" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR0746 vs CAR CAR2057", "Status: Transferred ARB Project vs Registered", "Credits issued by vintage: 2022:42364, 2023:77370, 2025:43934 vs 2024:67365" ], "reason": "Both listings describe the Beckley Pocahontas Mine Methane Incineration Project in Beckley, West Virginia, developed by Keyrock Energy LLC using the ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xf0482e1229cb8baab00d6abe997619465ec8b5efbb38fa1988b1b6b3163ffef2", "proof": [ "0x35a36cd2dcd472ede1aebf730203ea2cd4ad0ceb27cb20d4836c93a14995b797", "0x34e7acba7cd2913941c4fe01456f7bb8943cdc591e270215d72a209736522262", "0x09f1deadfd2bd3a8e247bcf836668dbdf4f7d7ba17dea5a5154ddef5a1cd5655", "0x52dac7098829a719e43568be6a3780ceee65e64e74f2141248c25159df8e56d0", "0xa701f5d9cc00fa91a8ee09aab687e0a1cf0cd4997188d40a2afe672883a694cc", "0x5b9ccb750fb45c8ba42f45af2592f5656edc8e56e2aca0608a56c935d485b546" ] }, { "id": "ACR0761~CAR2091", "a": "ACR0761", "b": "CAR2091", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 1, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0761", "Project Name": "Federal 2 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "WEST VIRGINIA", "Project Site Location": "Fairview", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 768166, "Total Credits Retired": 391676, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 115415, "2023": 321388, "2024": 331363 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2091", "Project Name": "Federal 2 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "WEST VIRGINIA", "Project Site Location": "Fairview", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment,LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 337485, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 337485 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Federal 2 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "value_b": "Federal 2 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / WEST VIRGINIA / Fairview", "value_b": "United States / WEST VIRGINIA / Fairview" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Environment,LLC" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR0761 vs CAR CAR2091", "Status: Transferred ARB Project vs Registered", "Credits issued by vintage: 2022:115415, 2023:321388, 2024:331363 vs 2025:337485" ], "reason": "Both listings describe the Federal 2 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project in Fairview, West Virginia, using the ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x6a02fd5906c91edd50358ae293d29f09755875c2d016af8e7d03875e78bd641b", "proof": [ "0x8679d5e16c27751e8703fc561cda35d38f44a899bd4f74c96850ae70fd5f7482", "0xce8055caf9d238fddb48eea1e32d89987eb93ebf2faced86e47e6801fadf3b16", "0x09f1deadfd2bd3a8e247bcf836668dbdf4f7d7ba17dea5a5154ddef5a1cd5655", "0x52dac7098829a719e43568be6a3780ceee65e64e74f2141248c25159df8e56d0", "0xa701f5d9cc00fa91a8ee09aab687e0a1cf0cd4997188d40a2afe672883a694cc", "0x5b9ccb750fb45c8ba42f45af2592f5656edc8e56e2aca0608a56c935d485b546" ] }, { "id": "ACR0771~CAR2088", "a": "ACR0771", "b": "CAR2088", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 1, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0771", "Project Name": "Lowry Mine Methane Incineration Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "PENNSYLVANIA", "Project Site Location": "Homer City", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Energy LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 162245, "Total Credits Retired": 61069, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 49718, "2023": 59230, "2024": 53297 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2088", "Project Name": "Lowry Mine Methane Incineration Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "PENNSYLVANIA", "Project Site Location": "Homer City", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Energy, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 36220, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 36220 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Lowry Mine Methane Incineration Project", "value_b": "Lowry Mine Methane Incineration Project" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / PENNSYLVANIA / Homer City", "value_b": "United States / PENNSYLVANIA / Homer City" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Energy LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Energy, LLC" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR0771 vs CAR CAR2088", "Status: Transferred ARB Project vs Registered", "Credits issued by vintage: 2022:49718, 2023:59230, 2024:53297 vs 2025:36220" ], "reason": "Both listings describe the Lowry Mine Methane Incineration Project in Homer City, Pennsylvania, developed by Keyrock Energy LLC using the ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x8679d5e16c27751e8703fc561cda35d38f44a899bd4f74c96850ae70fd5f7482", "proof": [ "0x6a02fd5906c91edd50358ae293d29f09755875c2d016af8e7d03875e78bd641b", "0xce8055caf9d238fddb48eea1e32d89987eb93ebf2faced86e47e6801fadf3b16", "0x09f1deadfd2bd3a8e247bcf836668dbdf4f7d7ba17dea5a5154ddef5a1cd5655", "0x52dac7098829a719e43568be6a3780ceee65e64e74f2141248c25159df8e56d0", "0xa701f5d9cc00fa91a8ee09aab687e0a1cf0cd4997188d40a2afe672883a694cc", "0x5b9ccb750fb45c8ba42f45af2592f5656edc8e56e2aca0608a56c935d485b546" ] }, { "id": "ACR0807~CAR2058", "a": "ACR0807", "b": "CAR2058", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 1, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0807", "Project Name": "Shoal Creek Mine Methane Incineration Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ALABAMA", "Project Site Location": "Northport", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Energy LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 120166, "Total Credits Retired": 92177, "issued_by_vintage": { "2023": 65859, "2024": 54307 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2058", "Project Name": "Shoal Creek Mine Methane Incineration Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ALABAMA", "Project Site Location": "Northport", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Energy, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 191553, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 71264, "2026": 120289 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Shoal Creek Mine Methane Incineration Project", "value_b": "Shoal Creek Mine Methane Incineration Project" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / ALABAMA / Northport", "value_b": "United States / ALABAMA / Northport" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Energy LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Energy, LLC" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR0807 vs CAR CAR2058", "Status: Transferred ARB Project vs Registered", "Credits issued by vintage: 2023:65859, 2024:54307 vs 2025:71264, 2026:120289" ], "reason": "Both listings describe the Shoal Creek Mine Methane Incineration Project in Northport, Alabama, developed by Keyrock Energy LLC using the ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x475b8330b7cc9ab60202a8c90f5ac3b32f5ee05233348d5e42e354715f0e322c", "proof": [ "0xea60c3d2cb881d1ded31d718261ad4dac84e758cd2b6e7fb66259dc097b80cf0", "0x38e1e3ca2369155e21ec66ef719ad698261466c0f75154035d5588ff3c00e972", "0x71c5287fcbd385ca59dfc20738908e09b25c048c3073a50a77dc5a237f3f7b91", "0x52dac7098829a719e43568be6a3780ceee65e64e74f2141248c25159df8e56d0", "0xa701f5d9cc00fa91a8ee09aab687e0a1cf0cd4997188d40a2afe672883a694cc", "0x5b9ccb750fb45c8ba42f45af2592f5656edc8e56e2aca0608a56c935d485b546" ] }, { "id": "ACR0841~CAR2056", "a": "ACR0841", "b": "CAR2056", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 1, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0841", "Project Name": "American Eagle Mine Methane Incineration Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "WEST VIRGINIA", "Project Site Location": "Cabin Creek", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Energy LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 293279, "Total Credits Retired": 118003, "issued_by_vintage": { "2023": 113844, "2024": 179435 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2056", "Project Name": "American Eagle Mine Methane Incineration Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "WEST VIRGINIA", "Project Site Location": "Cabin Creek", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Energy, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 516161, "Total Credits Retired": 7000, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 260294, "2026": 255867 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "American Eagle Mine Methane Incineration Project", "value_b": "American Eagle Mine Methane Incineration Project" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / WEST VIRGINIA / Cabin Creek", "value_b": "United States / WEST VIRGINIA / Cabin Creek" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Energy LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Energy, LLC" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR0841 vs CAR CAR2056", "Status: Transferred ARB Project vs Registered", "Credits issued by vintage: 2023:113844, 2024:179435 vs 2025:260294, 2026:255867" ], "reason": "Both listings describe the American Eagle Mine Methane Incineration Project located in United States / WEST VIRGINIA / Cabin Creek using the ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xea60c3d2cb881d1ded31d718261ad4dac84e758cd2b6e7fb66259dc097b80cf0", "proof": [ "0x475b8330b7cc9ab60202a8c90f5ac3b32f5ee05233348d5e42e354715f0e322c", "0x38e1e3ca2369155e21ec66ef719ad698261466c0f75154035d5588ff3c00e972", "0x71c5287fcbd385ca59dfc20738908e09b25c048c3073a50a77dc5a237f3f7b91", "0x52dac7098829a719e43568be6a3780ceee65e64e74f2141248c25159df8e56d0", "0xa701f5d9cc00fa91a8ee09aab687e0a1cf0cd4997188d40a2afe672883a694cc", "0x5b9ccb750fb45c8ba42f45af2592f5656edc8e56e2aca0608a56c935d485b546" ] }, { "id": "ACR0235~CAR957", "a": "ACR0235", "b": "CAR957", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.975, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0235", "Project Name": "Synergy Biogas, LLC", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Listed - Active ARB Project", "Scope": "Agriculture", "Type": "Manure Methane Digester", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Capturing and Destroying Methane from Manure Management Systems", "Country": "United States", "State": "NEW YORK", "Project Site Location": "Wyoming", "Project Developer": "3Degrees Group, Inc.", "Total Credits Issued": 48409, "Total Credits Retired": 48409, "issued_by_vintage": { "2015": 6904, "2016": 8081, "2017": 7020, "2018": 6257, "2019": 6216, "2020": 5107, "2021": 8824 }, "notes": "The project developer through v10 was Camco EAM, LLC" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR957", "Project Name": "Synergy Biogas, LLC", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Agriculture", "Type": "Manure Methane Digester", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Capturing and Destroying Methane from Manure Management Systems", "Country": "United States", "State": "NEW YORK", "Project Site Location": "Wyoming, NY", "Project Developer": "3Degrees Group, Inc", "Total Credits Issued": 24670, "Total Credits Retired": 24670, "issued_by_vintage": { "2013": 7001, "2014": 7924, "2024": 9745 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Synergy Biogas, LLC", "value_b": "Synergy Biogas, LLC" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "3Degrees Group, Inc.", "value_b": "3Degrees Group, Inc" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Agriculture / Manure Methane Digester", "value_b": "Agriculture / Manure Methane Digester" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Capturing and Destroying Methane from Manurech", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Capturing and Destroying Methane from Manurech" }, { "field": "Country / State", "value_a": "United States / NEW YORK", "value_b": "United States / NEW YORK" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR0235 vs CAR CAR957", "Site: Wyoming vs Wyoming, NY", "Status: Listed - Active ARB Project vs Registered", "Credits issued by vintage: 2015-2021 vs 2013, 2014, 2024" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a project named Synergy Biogas, LLC developed by 3Degrees Group, Inc. involving an Agriculture / Manure Methane Digester using the ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Capturing and Destroying Methane from Manure Management Systems.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xfb7a07897f55f90ca119bfca78cf8966d15b3875ee07690b8fe9fc15f839bf9e", "proof": [ "0xc90bc394f0bc323ce0bcd9f050c4a8aa2c0a3054438e641d0408cb9f37188930", "0x28845c6264acc6ad283e4575b8f2f50e0bf8cfec935e14c2abe70ba5dd0a5ac8", "0x71c5287fcbd385ca59dfc20738908e09b25c048c3073a50a77dc5a237f3f7b91", "0x52dac7098829a719e43568be6a3780ceee65e64e74f2141248c25159df8e56d0", "0xa701f5d9cc00fa91a8ee09aab687e0a1cf0cd4997188d40a2afe672883a694cc", "0x5b9ccb750fb45c8ba42f45af2592f5656edc8e56e2aca0608a56c935d485b546" ] }, { "id": "ACR0572~CAR2253", "a": "ACR0572", "b": "CAR2253", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.9667, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0572", "Project Name": "Pattiki 2 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Crossville", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 179064, "Total Credits Retired": 109555, "issued_by_vintage": { "2020": 13824, "2021": 32325, "2022": 35680, "2023": 30181, "2024": 67054 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2253", "Project Name": "Pattiki 2 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Crossville, IL", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment,LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 93013, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 93013 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Pattiki 2 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "value_b": "Pattiki 2 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Environment,LLC" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" }, { "field": "Country / State", "value_a": "United States / ILLINOIS", "value_b": "United States / ILLINOIS" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR0572 vs CAR CAR2253", "Status: Transferred ARB Project vs Registered", "Site: Crossville vs Crossville, IL", "Credits issued by vintage: 2020-2024 vs 2025" ], "reason": "Both listings describe the Pattiki 2 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project developed by Keyrock Environment LLC using the ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xc90bc394f0bc323ce0bcd9f050c4a8aa2c0a3054438e641d0408cb9f37188930", "proof": [ "0xfb7a07897f55f90ca119bfca78cf8966d15b3875ee07690b8fe9fc15f839bf9e", "0x28845c6264acc6ad283e4575b8f2f50e0bf8cfec935e14c2abe70ba5dd0a5ac8", "0x71c5287fcbd385ca59dfc20738908e09b25c048c3073a50a77dc5a237f3f7b91", "0x52dac7098829a719e43568be6a3780ceee65e64e74f2141248c25159df8e56d0", "0xa701f5d9cc00fa91a8ee09aab687e0a1cf0cd4997188d40a2afe672883a694cc", "0x5b9ccb750fb45c8ba42f45af2592f5656edc8e56e2aca0608a56c935d485b546" ] }, { "id": "ACR0607~CAR2255", "a": "ACR0607", "b": "CAR2255", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.9667, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0607", "Project Name": "Deep Mine 26 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "VIRGINIA", "Project Site Location": "Clintwood", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 239292, "Total Credits Retired": 104993, "issued_by_vintage": { "2020": 17318, "2021": 32294, "2022": 28722, "2023": 51262, "2024": 109696 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2255", "Project Name": "Deep Mine 26 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "VIRGINIA", "Project Site Location": "Clintwood, VA", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment,LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 78357, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 78357 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Deep Mine 26 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "value_b": "Deep Mine 26 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Environment,LLC" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" }, { "field": "Country / State", "value_a": "United States / VIRGINIA", "value_b": "United States / VIRGINIA" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR0607 vs CAR CAR2255", "Site: Clintwood vs Clintwood, VA", "Status: Transferred ARB Project vs Registered", "Credits issued by vintage: 2020-2024 vs 2025" ], "reason": "Both listings describe the Deep Mine 26 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project developed by Keyrock Environment LLC using the ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x8e737ba4379ce6398d1f6b3b23d0d12362310541ac222977536f0c47a8cb5834", "proof": [ "0x3cf1a30e2ccf286206f6a86d4c282a7434c47c0713e12e1a2f174679c2a51b1d", "0x826183b10dfa7e9382ba74bb65c477b27ea3ab14fc70c581200d6f2c2cf0aac7", "0x653f5c781266d6c7a014f411075ea5310989a120b77d2f990d6b877c0b3e3343", "0x4e96d6b47e460eff71a097f5d5ad237699e7867b66a98d0b3896dc44feb69080", "0x3d21751d65d8a00cba2046e412f904e35af26365115e95b40e7ff205fd07b5f2", "0xc926fff5463964ac1b15fc422c25975a3295227330b079b080923a06acc8b97e" ] }, { "id": "ACR0808~CAR2217", "a": "ACR0808", "b": "CAR2217", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.9667, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0808", "Project Name": "Rend Lake Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Bonnie", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 152429, "Total Credits Retired": 85699, "issued_by_vintage": { "2023": 112376, "2024": 40053 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2217", "Project Name": "Rend Lake Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Bonnie, IL", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment,LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 32223, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 32223 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Rend Lake Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "value_b": "Rend Lake Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Environment,LLC" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" }, { "field": "Country / State", "value_a": "United States / ILLINOIS", "value_b": "United States / ILLINOIS" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR0808 vs CAR CAR2217", "Site: Bonnie vs Bonnie, IL", "Status: Transferred ARB Project vs Registered", "Credits issued by vintage: 2023:112376, 2024:40053 vs 2025:32223" ], "reason": "Both listings describe the Rend Lake Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project developed by Keyrock Environment LLC using the ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x3cf1a30e2ccf286206f6a86d4c282a7434c47c0713e12e1a2f174679c2a51b1d", "proof": [ "0x8e737ba4379ce6398d1f6b3b23d0d12362310541ac222977536f0c47a8cb5834", "0x826183b10dfa7e9382ba74bb65c477b27ea3ab14fc70c581200d6f2c2cf0aac7", "0x653f5c781266d6c7a014f411075ea5310989a120b77d2f990d6b877c0b3e3343", "0x4e96d6b47e460eff71a097f5d5ad237699e7867b66a98d0b3896dc44feb69080", "0x3d21751d65d8a00cba2046e412f904e35af26365115e95b40e7ff205fd07b5f2", "0xc926fff5463964ac1b15fc422c25975a3295227330b079b080923a06acc8b97e" ] }, { "id": "ACR0674~CAR2135", "a": "ACR0674", "b": "CAR2135", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.96, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0674", "Project Name": "Affinity Mine Methane Incineration Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "WEST VIRGINIA", "Project Site Location": "Crab Orchard", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Energy LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 152243, "Total Credits Retired": 128592, "issued_by_vintage": { "2021": 55569, "2022": 41618, "2023": 32075, "2024": 22981 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2135", "Project Name": "Affinity Mine Methane Incineration Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "WEST VIRGINIA", "Project Site Location": "Crab Orchad", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Energy, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 32794, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 32794 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Affinity Mine Methane Incineration Project", "value_b": "Affinity Mine Methane Incineration Project" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" }, { "field": "Country / State", "value_a": "United States / WEST VIRGINIA", "value_b": "United States / WEST VIRGINIA" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR0674 vs CAR CAR2135", "Site: Crab Orchard vs Crab Orchad", "Status: Transferred ARB Project vs Registered", "Credits issued by vintage: 2021:55569, 2022:41618, 2023:32075, 2024:22981 vs 2025:32794" ], "reason": "Both listings describe the Affinity Mine Methane Incineration Project using the ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects in United States / WEST VIRGINIA.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xa801d2ec673b26b1e3b2c810ad017774160c22f8ceb625d044fa770a803d7677", "proof": [ "0x8a86ba52438d9698df35330f83f5287b20751cc6bdc1cd6cdae80f49382bb1f4", "0x2b08c094f8dde7cc1b1a15a6c5946aa4b83ba90c88a44ad4817c9482f98f5ac2", "0x653f5c781266d6c7a014f411075ea5310989a120b77d2f990d6b877c0b3e3343", "0x4e96d6b47e460eff71a097f5d5ad237699e7867b66a98d0b3896dc44feb69080", "0x3d21751d65d8a00cba2046e412f904e35af26365115e95b40e7ff205fd07b5f2", "0xc926fff5463964ac1b15fc422c25975a3295227330b079b080923a06acc8b97e" ] }, { "id": "ACR0806~CAR2167", "a": "ACR0806", "b": "CAR2167", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.95, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0806", "Project Name": "Bonny Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "WEST VIRGINIA", "Project Site Location": "Mount Hope", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 181487, "Total Credits Retired": 104469, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 49803, "2023": 57293, "2024": 74391 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2167", "Project Name": "Bonny Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "WEST VIRGINIA", "Project Site Location": "Near Mt. Hope", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment,LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 86782, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 86782 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Bonny Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "value_b": "Bonny Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Environment,LLC" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" }, { "field": "Country / State", "value_a": "United States / WEST VIRGINIA", "value_b": "United States / WEST VIRGINIA" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR0806 vs CAR CAR2167", "Site: Mount Hope vs Near Mt. Hope", "Status: Transferred ARB Project vs Registered", "Credits issued by vintage: 2022:49803, 2023:57293, 2024:74391 vs 2025:86782" ], "reason": "Both listings describe the Bonny Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project developed by Keyrock Environment LLC using the ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x8a86ba52438d9698df35330f83f5287b20751cc6bdc1cd6cdae80f49382bb1f4", "proof": [ "0xa801d2ec673b26b1e3b2c810ad017774160c22f8ceb625d044fa770a803d7677", "0x2b08c094f8dde7cc1b1a15a6c5946aa4b83ba90c88a44ad4817c9482f98f5ac2", "0x653f5c781266d6c7a014f411075ea5310989a120b77d2f990d6b877c0b3e3343", "0x4e96d6b47e460eff71a097f5d5ad237699e7867b66a98d0b3896dc44feb69080", "0x3d21751d65d8a00cba2046e412f904e35af26365115e95b40e7ff205fd07b5f2", "0xc926fff5463964ac1b15fc422c25975a3295227330b079b080923a06acc8b97e" ] }, { "id": "ACR0931~CAR2112", "a": "ACR0931", "b": "CAR2112", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.9429, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0931", "Project Name": "Kielty Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "WEST VIRGINIA", "Project Site Location": "192 Lick Rd, Delbarton, WV", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 118530, "Total Credits Retired": 118530, "issued_by_vintage": { "2024": 118530 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2112", "Project Name": "Kielty Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "WEST VIRGINIA", "Project Site Location": "Delbarton", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment,LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 147508, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 147508 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Kielty Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "value_b": "Kielty Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Environment,LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / WEST VIRGINIA / 192 Lick Rd, Delbarton, WV", "value_b": "United States / WEST VIRGINIA / Delbarton" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR0931 vs CAR CAR2112", "Status: Transferred ARB Project vs Registered", "Credits issued by vintage: 2024:118530 vs 2025:147508", "Description: Mine methane capture and on-site incineration vs [Missing]" ], "reason": "Both listings describe the Kielty Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project developed by Keyrock Environment LLC in West Virginia using the ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x974de1cc6054cfa7124381772dd2cdd1532bef525ae5403d67a160fa75807042", "proof": [ "0x2dff03fcc6125fcce790b71bf5e0dca9ed61f8817b2fd61e5483505ec000bbf1", "0xc97d0510343e599e747a23f1369b8e1fbce0729d8534b3a02c7d58157049f28b", "0x835e37e325b042c63d7f57760b0ebc832d5608683de96de9440b18f934b3f2cb", "0x4e96d6b47e460eff71a097f5d5ad237699e7867b66a98d0b3896dc44feb69080", "0x3d21751d65d8a00cba2046e412f904e35af26365115e95b40e7ff205fd07b5f2", "0xc926fff5463964ac1b15fc422c25975a3295227330b079b080923a06acc8b97e" ] }, { "id": "ACR0743~CAR2055", "a": "ACR0743", "b": "CAR2055", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.9333, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0743", "Project Name": "Urling Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "PENNSYLVANIA", "Project Site Location": "Shelocta", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 21850, "Total Credits Retired": 15841, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 3665, "2023": 9378, "2024": 8807 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2055", "Project Name": "Urling Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "PENNSYLVANIA", "Project Site Location": "Shelcota", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment,LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 12081, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 5937, "2026": 6144 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Urling Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "value_b": "Urling Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" }, { "field": "Country / State", "value_a": "United States / PENNSYLVANIA", "value_b": "United States / PENNSYLVANIA" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR0743 vs CAR CAR2055", "Developer: Keyrock Environment LLC vs Keyrock Environment,LLC", "Site: Shelocta vs Shelcota", "Status: Transferred ARB Project vs Registered" ], "reason": "Both listings describe the Urling Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project using the ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects in United States / PENNSYLVANIA.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x2dff03fcc6125fcce790b71bf5e0dca9ed61f8817b2fd61e5483505ec000bbf1", "proof": [ "0x974de1cc6054cfa7124381772dd2cdd1532bef525ae5403d67a160fa75807042", "0xc97d0510343e599e747a23f1369b8e1fbce0729d8534b3a02c7d58157049f28b", "0x835e37e325b042c63d7f57760b0ebc832d5608683de96de9440b18f934b3f2cb", "0x4e96d6b47e460eff71a097f5d5ad237699e7867b66a98d0b3896dc44feb69080", "0x3d21751d65d8a00cba2046e412f904e35af26365115e95b40e7ff205fd07b5f2", "0xc926fff5463964ac1b15fc422c25975a3295227330b079b080923a06acc8b97e" ] }, { "id": "ACR1009~CAR2111", "a": "ACR1009", "b": "CAR2111", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.9333, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR1009", "Project Name": "Green Valley Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "6010 State Line Rd, Paris Township", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 31850, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2024": 31850 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2111", "Project Name": "Green Valley Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Paris", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment,LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 159383, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 159383 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Green Valley Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "value_b": "Green Valley Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Environment,LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / ILLINOIS / 6010 State Line Rd, Paris Township", "value_b": "United States / ILLINOIS / Paris" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR1009 vs CAR CAR2111", "Status: Transferred ARB Project vs Registered", "Credits issued by vintage: 2024:31850 vs 2025:159383", "Description: Mine methane capture and on-site incineration vs [Missing]" ], "reason": "Both listings describe the Green Valley Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project developed by Keyrock Environment LLC in Illinois using the ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x72974009f80051396e73a45353e095d4bed3c2445230de4c1233de0263ee76a1", "proof": [ "0x8a059d46e72832761caaba22e5dd6386d1ef8fd31b174177bbe967ce76c1304c", "0x2bc5a19b25b6d4e2105b047c72e0c71832d19b9a248755af36d1b46419cbca91", "0x835e37e325b042c63d7f57760b0ebc832d5608683de96de9440b18f934b3f2cb", "0x4e96d6b47e460eff71a097f5d5ad237699e7867b66a98d0b3896dc44feb69080", "0x3d21751d65d8a00cba2046e412f904e35af26365115e95b40e7ff205fd07b5f2", "0xc926fff5463964ac1b15fc422c25975a3295227330b079b080923a06acc8b97e" ] }, { "id": "CAR448~VCS1680", "a": "CAR448", "b": "VCS1680", "registry_a": "CAR", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.925, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "CAR448", "Project Name": "Tri-Community Recycling and Sanitary Landfill", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Waste Management", "Type": "Landfill Methane", "Methodology / Protocol": "CAR U.S. Landfill Protocol", "Country": "United States", "State": "MAINE", "Project Site Location": "Fort Fairfield, ME", "Project Developer": "3Degrees Group, Inc", "Total Credits Issued": 4091, "Total Credits Retired": 319, "issued_by_vintage": { "2010": 4091 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1680", "Project Name": "Tri-Community Recycling and Sanitary Landfill Project", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Under development", "Scope": "Waste Management", "Type": "Landfill Methane", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0001 Flaring or use of landfill gas", "Country": "United States", "State": "MAINE", "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "3Degrees Group, Inc..", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "3Degrees Group, Inc", "value_b": "3Degrees Group, Inc.." }, { "field": "Country / State", "value_a": "United States / MAINE", "value_b": "United States / MAINE" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Waste Management / Landfill Methane", "value_b": "Waste Management / Landfill Methane" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: CAR CAR448 vs VCS VCS1680", "Name: Tri-Community Recycling and Sanitary Landfill vs Tri-Community Recycling and Sanitary Landfill Project", "Methodology: CAR U.S. Landfill Protocol vs ACM0001 Flaring or use of landfill gas", "Status: Completed vs Under development" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a Waste Management / Landfill Methane project in United States / MAINE developed by 3Degrees Group, Inc.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x8a059d46e72832761caaba22e5dd6386d1ef8fd31b174177bbe967ce76c1304c", "proof": [ "0x72974009f80051396e73a45353e095d4bed3c2445230de4c1233de0263ee76a1", "0x2bc5a19b25b6d4e2105b047c72e0c71832d19b9a248755af36d1b46419cbca91", "0x835e37e325b042c63d7f57760b0ebc832d5608683de96de9440b18f934b3f2cb", "0x4e96d6b47e460eff71a097f5d5ad237699e7867b66a98d0b3896dc44feb69080", "0x3d21751d65d8a00cba2046e412f904e35af26365115e95b40e7ff205fd07b5f2", "0xc926fff5463964ac1b15fc422c25975a3295227330b079b080923a06acc8b97e" ] }, { "id": "GS12028~VCS4209", "a": "GS12028", "b": "VCS4209", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "Brazil", "screen_score": 0.9, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS12028", "Project Name": "Oeste de Caucaia Landfill Project Activity", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Listed", "Scope": "Waste Management", "Type": "Landfill Methane", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0001 Flaring or use of landfill gas", "Country": "Brazil", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "GNR FORTALEZA VALORIZACAO DE BIOGAS LTDA", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS4209", "Project Name": "Oeste de Caucaia Landfill Project Activity", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Waste Management", "Type": "Landfill Methane", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0001 Flaring or use of landfill gas", "Country": "Brazil", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "GNR FORTALEZA VALORIZACAO DE BIOGAS LTDA", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Oeste de Caucaia Landfill Project Activity", "value_b": "Oeste de Caucaia Landfill Project Activity" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "GNR FORTALEZA VALORIZACAO DE BIOGAS LTDA", "value_b": "GNR FORTALEZA VALORIZACAO DE BIOGAS LTDA" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "Brazil / None / None", "value_b": "Brazil / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Waste Management / Landfill Methane", "value_b": "Waste Management / Landfill Methane" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ACM0001 Flaring or use of landfill gas", "value_b": "ACM0001 Flaring or use of landfill gas" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS12028 vs VCS VCS4209", "Status: Listed vs Registered" ], "reason": "Both listings describe the Oeste de Caucaia Landfill Project Activity developed by GNR FORTALEZA VALORIZACAO DE BIOGAS LTDA in Brazil using methodology ACM0001 Flaring or use of landfill gas.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x5c16799418b2e81377f46b939e4f37936b685407b8e450a3f7c3821ad2fdf84f", "proof": [ "0x39fa567cd2fb3a9618967fc57bc011ff19df090c758d5b665c429ee46773f16d", "0x8d6823ee82a4906693fc9d53c3ffe618a5df7a1fdf3a6ece325b105ad9b6800f", "0xdcc9de14550ac5654871f5efaf897afdea1e9b44247c2375c2336772f2cc388b", "0x46369e3636de4337c95fed159e85ffa77d2c8056de265a03933502bf7ed1a594", "0x3d21751d65d8a00cba2046e412f904e35af26365115e95b40e7ff205fd07b5f2", "0xc926fff5463964ac1b15fc422c25975a3295227330b079b080923a06acc8b97e" ] }, { "id": "GS826~VCS1829", "a": "GS826", "b": "VCS1829", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.9, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS826", "Project Name": "Biomass based power project in Punjab India", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Listed", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Biomass", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Dee Development Engineers Pvt. Ltd.", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1829", "Project Name": "Biomass based power project in Punjab, India", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Under development", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Biomass", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Dee Development Engineers Pvt. Ltd.", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Dee Development Engineers Pvt. Ltd.", "value_b": "Dee Development Engineers Pvt. Ltd." }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Biomass", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Biomass" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation", "value_b": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation" }, { "field": "Credits issued by vintage", "value_a": "none", "value_b": "none" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS826 vs VCS VCS1829", "Name: Biomass based power project in Punjab India vs Biomass based power project in Punjab, India", "Status: Listed vs Under development" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a Biomass based power project in India developed by Dee Development Engineers Pvt. Ltd. using the AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation methodology.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x39fa567cd2fb3a9618967fc57bc011ff19df090c758d5b665c429ee46773f16d", "proof": [ "0x5c16799418b2e81377f46b939e4f37936b685407b8e450a3f7c3821ad2fdf84f", "0x8d6823ee82a4906693fc9d53c3ffe618a5df7a1fdf3a6ece325b105ad9b6800f", "0xdcc9de14550ac5654871f5efaf897afdea1e9b44247c2375c2336772f2cc388b", "0x46369e3636de4337c95fed159e85ffa77d2c8056de265a03933502bf7ed1a594", "0x3d21751d65d8a00cba2046e412f904e35af26365115e95b40e7ff205fd07b5f2", "0xc926fff5463964ac1b15fc422c25975a3295227330b079b080923a06acc8b97e" ] }, { "id": "GS4194~VCS1239", "a": "GS4194", "b": "VCS1239", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.9, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS4194", "Project Name": "Utilization of Biomass in Bricks Manufacturing By Ozone Envirotech Pvt. Ltd. (OEPL)", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Listed", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Brick Manufacturing Emission Reductions", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-III.Z. Fuel switch, process improvement and energy efficiency in brick manufacture", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Ozone Envirotech Private Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1239", "Project Name": "Utilization of Biomass in Bricks Manufacturing By Ozone Envirotech Pvt. Ltd. (OEPL)", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Under development", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Brick Manufacturing Emission Reductions", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-III.Z. Fuel switch, process improvement and energy efficiency in brick manufacture", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Ozone Envirotech Private Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Utilization of Biomass in Bricks Manufacturing By Ozone Envirotech Pvt. Ltd. (OE", "value_b": "Utilization of Biomass in Bricks Manufacturing By Ozone Envirotech Pvt. Ltd. (OE" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Ozone Envirotech Private Limited", "value_b": "Ozone Envirotech Private Limited" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Brick Manufacturing Emission Reductions", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Brick Manufacturing Emission Reductions" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "AMS-III.Z. Fuel switch, process improvement and energy efficiency in brick manuf", "value_b": "AMS-III.Z. Fuel switch, process improvement and energy efficiency in brick manuf" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS4194 vs VCS VCS1239", "Status: Listed vs Under development" ], "reason": "Both listings share the same Name, Developer, Country / State / Site, Scope / Type, and Methodology.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xd72736b5bfd26c759c0507df182b83072d4f9e5c76d4ea461d7bd325de7f7fd2", "proof": [ "0x1666b7ca34d6e3adf75ecf1570ce66c4e448739999029395f214a476c0dcab98", "0xc9d29aa858643dfece4e254f4731f21b21a12feeb52804e50ad5533b7e702ad6", "0xdcc9de14550ac5654871f5efaf897afdea1e9b44247c2375c2336772f2cc388b", "0x46369e3636de4337c95fed159e85ffa77d2c8056de265a03933502bf7ed1a594", "0x3d21751d65d8a00cba2046e412f904e35af26365115e95b40e7ff205fd07b5f2", "0xc926fff5463964ac1b15fc422c25975a3295227330b079b080923a06acc8b97e" ] }, { "id": "GS6279~VCS1819", "a": "GS6279", "b": "VCS1819", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.9, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS6279", "Project Name": "19.2 MWp Solar Power Project by HZL at Debari and Dariba Rajasthan", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Solar - Centralized", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Hindustan Zinc Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 58096, "Total Credits Retired": 28989, "issued_by_vintage": { "2019": 20076, "2020": 38020 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1819", "Project Name": "19.2 MWp Solar Power Project by HZL at Debari and Dariba, Rajasthan", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Withdrawn", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Solar - Centralized", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Hindustan Zinc Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 46473, "Total Credits Retired": 46473, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 20721, "2018": 25752 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Hindustan Zinc Limited", "value_b": "Hindustan Zinc Limited" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Solar - Centralized", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Solar - Centralized" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "value_b": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources" }, { "field": "Name", "value_a": "19.2 MWp Solar Power Project by HZL at Debari and Dariba Rajasthan", "value_b": "19.2 MWp Solar Power Project by HZL at Debari and Dariba, Rajasthan" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS6279 vs VCS VCS1819", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Withdrawn", "Credits issued by vintage: 2019:20076, 2020:38020 vs 2017:20721, 2018:25752" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a 19.2 MWp Solar Power Project by Hindustan Zinc Limited in India using methodology ACM0002.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x1666b7ca34d6e3adf75ecf1570ce66c4e448739999029395f214a476c0dcab98", "proof": [ "0xd72736b5bfd26c759c0507df182b83072d4f9e5c76d4ea461d7bd325de7f7fd2", "0xc9d29aa858643dfece4e254f4731f21b21a12feeb52804e50ad5533b7e702ad6", "0xdcc9de14550ac5654871f5efaf897afdea1e9b44247c2375c2336772f2cc388b", "0x46369e3636de4337c95fed159e85ffa77d2c8056de265a03933502bf7ed1a594", "0x3d21751d65d8a00cba2046e412f904e35af26365115e95b40e7ff205fd07b5f2", "0xc926fff5463964ac1b15fc422c25975a3295227330b079b080923a06acc8b97e" ] }, { "id": "GS6747~VCS1134", "a": "GS6747", "b": "VCS1134", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.9, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS6747", "Project Name": "52.50 MW Wind energy farm at Mokla Rajasthan by HZL", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": null, "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Hindustan Zinc Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 365994, "Total Credits Retired": 85642, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 55243, "2018": 96045, "2019": 118504, "2020": 96202 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1134", "Project Name": "52.50 MW Wind energy farm at Mokla Rajasthan by HZL", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Withdrawn", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Hindustan Zinc Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 417675, "Total Credits Retired": 343978, "issued_by_vintage": { "2011": 54123, "2012": 81984, "2013": 70048, "2014": 73338, "2015": 73697, "2016": 64485 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "52.50 MW Wind energy farm at Mokla Rajasthan by HZL", "value_b": "52.50 MW Wind energy farm at Mokla Rajasthan by HZL" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Hindustan Zinc Limited", "value_b": "Hindustan Zinc Limited" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS6747 vs VCS VCS1134", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Withdrawn", "Credits issued by vintage: 2017-2020 vs 2011-2016", "Methodology: Not listed in A vs ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a 52.50 MW Wind energy farm at Mokla Rajasthan by HZL developed by Hindustan Zinc Limited in India.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x410d13556a45ea9838a67d622f9a6561166b9a6807f48ced502e9a444e04c90b", "proof": [ "0x2ae987dccbcfdf3fe5d3ff0790825f3e8ba94ebff3dfb2ef1ef64db213ebd33e", "0xf35a67645ba6898f4bbf32759cd2ccca411028c042f8d3fc0ccd250854eef782", "0x703e1b24929fcc2b67c8213bba78634dd6138dbb6828108f60888e8345779123", "0x46369e3636de4337c95fed159e85ffa77d2c8056de265a03933502bf7ed1a594", "0x3d21751d65d8a00cba2046e412f904e35af26365115e95b40e7ff205fd07b5f2", "0xc926fff5463964ac1b15fc422c25975a3295227330b079b080923a06acc8b97e" ] }, { "id": "GS6748~VCS1136", "a": "GS6748", "b": "VCS1136", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.9, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS6748", "Project Name": "25.5 MW Wind Energy Farm at Nandurbar Maharashtra by HZL", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": null, "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Hindustan Zinc Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 351512, "Total Credits Retired": 171449, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 84693, "2018": 108162, "2019": 94451, "2020": 64206 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1136", "Project Name": "25.5 MW Wind Energy Farm at Nandurbar Maharashtra by HZL", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Withdrawn", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Hindustan Zinc Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 271222, "Total Credits Retired": 223718, "issued_by_vintage": { "2011": 4321, "2012": 57767, "2013": 57700, "2014": 47662, "2015": 47504, "2016": 56268 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "25.5 MW Wind Energy Farm at Nandurbar Maharashtra by HZL", "value_b": "25.5 MW Wind Energy Farm at Nandurbar Maharashtra by HZL" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Hindustan Zinc Limited", "value_b": "Hindustan Zinc Limited" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS6748 vs VCS VCS1136", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Withdrawn", "Credits issued by vintage: 2017:84693, 2018:108162, 2019:94451, 2020:64206 vs 2011:4321, 2012:57767, 2013:57700, 2014:47", "Methodology: [Missing] vs ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a 25.5 MW Wind Energy Farm at Nandurbar Maharashtra by HZL developed by Hindustan Zinc Limited in India.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x2ae987dccbcfdf3fe5d3ff0790825f3e8ba94ebff3dfb2ef1ef64db213ebd33e", "proof": [ "0x410d13556a45ea9838a67d622f9a6561166b9a6807f48ced502e9a444e04c90b", "0xf35a67645ba6898f4bbf32759cd2ccca411028c042f8d3fc0ccd250854eef782", "0x703e1b24929fcc2b67c8213bba78634dd6138dbb6828108f60888e8345779123", "0x46369e3636de4337c95fed159e85ffa77d2c8056de265a03933502bf7ed1a594", "0x3d21751d65d8a00cba2046e412f904e35af26365115e95b40e7ff205fd07b5f2", "0xc926fff5463964ac1b15fc422c25975a3295227330b079b080923a06acc8b97e" ] }, { "id": "GS6853~VCS344", "a": "GS6853", "b": "VCS344", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.9, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS6853", "Project Name": "Wind power project by HZL in Gujarat.", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Hindustan Zinc Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 665193, "Total Credits Retired": 194737, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 41895, "2018": 255976, "2019": 219560, "2020": 147762 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS344", "Project Name": "Wind power project by HZL in Gujarat.", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Withdrawn", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Hindustan Zinc Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 622581, "Total Credits Retired": 622581, "issued_by_vintage": { "2009": 217755, "2013": 17905, "2014": 126821, "2015": 133381, "2016": 126719 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Wind power project by HZL in Gujarat.", "value_b": "Wind power project by HZL in Gujarat." }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Hindustan Zinc Limited", "value_b": "Hindustan Zinc Limited" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "value_b": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS6853 vs VCS VCS344", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Withdrawn", "Credits issued by vintage: 2017:41895, 2018:255976, 2019:219560, 2020:147762 vs 2009:217755, 2013:17905, 2014:126821, 20" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a Wind power project by HZL in Gujarat in India using methodology ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x5a06f7bcaae2386887b5aed68ad815d8b5ce2fa4154307bbbcb39ba0453f2ce5", "proof": [ "0x76529c63a9bf9d93f3355c3144e649aa8f4571bb3f2e6596a09645a1fcb369f6", "0x8477265c27fb579c664e46945c442f053b6e80a505c5de44bd8940faa0b0e5f8", "0x703e1b24929fcc2b67c8213bba78634dd6138dbb6828108f60888e8345779123", "0x46369e3636de4337c95fed159e85ffa77d2c8056de265a03933502bf7ed1a594", "0x3d21751d65d8a00cba2046e412f904e35af26365115e95b40e7ff205fd07b5f2", "0xc926fff5463964ac1b15fc422c25975a3295227330b079b080923a06acc8b97e" ] }, { "id": "GS6855~VCS1135", "a": "GS6855", "b": "VCS1135", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.9, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS6855", "Project Name": "27.3 MW Wind energy farm at Mokla Rajasthan by HZL", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Hindustan Zinc Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 200437, "Total Credits Retired": 97442, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 12282, "2018": 68714, "2019": 63677, "2020": 55764 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1135", "Project Name": "27.3 MW Wind energy farm at Mokla Rajasthan by HZL", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Withdrawn", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Hindustan Zinc Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 194745, "Total Credits Retired": 122059, "issued_by_vintage": { "2011": 2516, "2012": 42344, "2013": 43177, "2014": 36025, "2015": 36661, "2016": 34022 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "27.3 MW Wind energy farm at Mokla Rajasthan by HZL", "value_b": "27.3 MW Wind energy farm at Mokla Rajasthan by HZL" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Hindustan Zinc Limited", "value_b": "Hindustan Zinc Limited" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "value_b": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS6855 vs VCS VCS1135", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Withdrawn", "Credits issued by vintage: 2017:12282, 2018:68714, 2019:63677, 2020:55764 vs 2011:2516, 2012:42344, 2013:43177, 2014:360" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a 27.3 MW Wind energy farm at Mokla Rajasthan by HZL developed by Hindustan Zinc Limited in India using methodology ACM0002.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x76529c63a9bf9d93f3355c3144e649aa8f4571bb3f2e6596a09645a1fcb369f6", "proof": [ "0x5a06f7bcaae2386887b5aed68ad815d8b5ce2fa4154307bbbcb39ba0453f2ce5", "0x8477265c27fb579c664e46945c442f053b6e80a505c5de44bd8940faa0b0e5f8", "0x703e1b24929fcc2b67c8213bba78634dd6138dbb6828108f60888e8345779123", "0x46369e3636de4337c95fed159e85ffa77d2c8056de265a03933502bf7ed1a594", "0x3d21751d65d8a00cba2046e412f904e35af26365115e95b40e7ff205fd07b5f2", "0xc926fff5463964ac1b15fc422c25975a3295227330b079b080923a06acc8b97e" ] }, { "id": "GS6856~VCS1138", "a": "GS6856", "b": "VCS1138", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.9, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS6856", "Project Name": "9 MW Wind Energy Farm at Jodhpur Rajasthan by HZL", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": null, "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Hindustan Zinc Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 44008, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 5792, "2018": 14678, "2019": 13424, "2020": 10114 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1138", "Project Name": "9 MW Wind Energy Farm at Jodhpur Rajasthan by HZL", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Withdrawn", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Hindustan Zinc Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 78971, "Total Credits Retired": 78971, "issued_by_vintage": { "2011": 2355, "2012": 17047, "2013": 14539, "2014": 15291, "2015": 15883, "2016": 13856 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "9 MW Wind Energy Farm at Jodhpur Rajasthan by HZL", "value_b": "9 MW Wind Energy Farm at Jodhpur Rajasthan by HZL" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Hindustan Zinc Limited", "value_b": "Hindustan Zinc Limited" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS6856 vs VCS VCS1138", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Withdrawn", "Credits issued by vintage: 2017-2020 vs 2011-2016", "Methodology: Not listed in A vs AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a 9 MW Wind Energy Farm at Jodhpur Rajasthan by HZL developed by Hindustan Zinc Limited in India.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xb95a26b178a828773babb59801592db97e855a98d2fc07fe320daa85c07ef442", "proof": [ "0xf7ba638c5a395a203ace5e20d1766fc135ac050ad888b73147e5b55201e75a5d", "0xdd0be04db1ed3a1f07a810e942643723801ef5887d93aeac934786c8761518f8", "0xb072ced025cb32ad1f2ab173c63bc700dd4bbacb002c004916f6c9c687981e37", "0xa5db51b2848283654f261a75838afe4771c06a10de8c18b11e6abb671b38fa8f", "0x4f786c84d50cdbfb3e19e9423bb3b9fee90090d4a4cf671b059800b4b8eb1688", "0xc926fff5463964ac1b15fc422c25975a3295227330b079b080923a06acc8b97e" ] }, { "id": "GS6857~VCS1139", "a": "GS6857", "b": "VCS1139", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.9, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS6857", "Project Name": "15 MW Wind energy farm at Gopalpura Karnataka by HZL", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Hindustan Zinc Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 100497, "Total Credits Retired": 34661, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 4856, "2018": 19158, "2019": 36468, "2020": 19934, "2021": 17516, "2022": 2565 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1139", "Project Name": "15 MW Wind energy farm at Gopalpura, Karnataka by HZL", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Withdrawn", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Hindustan Zinc Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 129185, "Total Credits Retired": 129185, "issued_by_vintage": { "2011": 19544, "2012": 23571, "2013": 23145, "2014": 21315, "2015": 19241, "2016": 22369 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Hindustan Zinc Limited", "value_b": "Hindustan Zinc Limited" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation", "value_b": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation" }, { "field": "Name", "value_a": "15 MW Wind energy farm at Gopalpura Karnataka by HZL", "value_b": "15 MW Wind energy farm at Gopalpura, Karnataka by HZL" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS6857 vs VCS VCS1139", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Withdrawn", "Credits issued by vintage: 2017-2022 vs 2011-2016" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a 15 MW Wind energy farm at Gopalpura Karnataka by the developer Hindustan Zinc Limited using the AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation methodology.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xf7ba638c5a395a203ace5e20d1766fc135ac050ad888b73147e5b55201e75a5d", "proof": [ "0xb95a26b178a828773babb59801592db97e855a98d2fc07fe320daa85c07ef442", "0xdd0be04db1ed3a1f07a810e942643723801ef5887d93aeac934786c8761518f8", "0xb072ced025cb32ad1f2ab173c63bc700dd4bbacb002c004916f6c9c687981e37", "0xa5db51b2848283654f261a75838afe4771c06a10de8c18b11e6abb671b38fa8f", "0x4f786c84d50cdbfb3e19e9423bb3b9fee90090d4a4cf671b059800b4b8eb1688", "0xc926fff5463964ac1b15fc422c25975a3295227330b079b080923a06acc8b97e" ] }, { "id": "GS6858~VCS1137", "a": "GS6858", "b": "VCS1137", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.9, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS6858", "Project Name": "21 MW Wind energy farm at Palladam TamilNadu by HZL", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Hindustan Zinc Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 125706, "Total Credits Retired": 26633, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 14030, "2018": 53877, "2019": 30774, "2020": 27025 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1137", "Project Name": "21 MW Wind energy farm at Palladam, TamilNadu by HZL", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Withdrawn", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Hindustan Zinc Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 173385, "Total Credits Retired": 137949, "issued_by_vintage": { "2011": 233, "2012": 43315, "2013": 31797, "2014": 33839, "2015": 25423, "2016": 38778 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Hindustan Zinc Limited", "value_b": "Hindustan Zinc Limited" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "value_b": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources" }, { "field": "Name", "value_a": "21 MW Wind energy farm at Palladam TamilNadu by HZL", "value_b": "21 MW Wind energy farm at Palladam, TamilNadu by HZL" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS6858 vs VCS VCS1137", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Withdrawn", "Credits issued by vintage: 2017:14030, 2018:53877, 2019:30774, 2020:27025 vs 2011:233, 2012:43315, 2013:31797, 2014:3383", "Description: Present in Listing A, missing in Listing B" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a 21 MW Wind energy farm at Palladam TamilNadu by Hindustan Zinc Limited using methodology ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xf707593f8e17bce028df36caaa03f18edb9883d9949faa7533c77e953f526b1a", "proof": [ "0x645d9d4f75ec1dc8710092e213adbd5b7cf7146a4e09ff9d3bf10b1f878f8f0e", "0x0c6bd7c31b65dfd4b786bfd85cb5df03827786bbaa6eb0781e420deed729aa6a", "0xb072ced025cb32ad1f2ab173c63bc700dd4bbacb002c004916f6c9c687981e37", "0xa5db51b2848283654f261a75838afe4771c06a10de8c18b11e6abb671b38fa8f", "0x4f786c84d50cdbfb3e19e9423bb3b9fee90090d4a4cf671b059800b4b8eb1688", "0xc926fff5463964ac1b15fc422c25975a3295227330b079b080923a06acc8b97e" ] }, { "id": "GS12382~VCS4032", "a": "GS12382", "b": "VCS4032", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.9, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS12382", "Project Name": "Improved agricultural practices for Rice cultivation in India", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Agriculture", "Type": "Rice Emission Reductions", "Methodology / Protocol": null, "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Kosher Climate India Pvt Ltd.", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS4032", "Project Name": "Improved Agricultural Practices for Rice Cultivation in India", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Withdrawn", "Scope": "Agriculture", "Type": "Rice Emission Reductions", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-III.AU. Methane emission reduction by adjusted water management practice in rice cultivation", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Kosher Climate India Pvt. Ltd.", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Kosher Climate India Pvt Ltd.", "value_b": "Kosher Climate India Pvt. Ltd." }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Agriculture / Rice Emission Reductions", "value_b": "Agriculture / Rice Emission Reductions" }, { "field": "Credits issued by vintage", "value_a": "none", "value_b": "none" }, { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Improved agricultural practices for Rice cultivation in India", "value_b": "Improved Agricultural Practices for Rice Cultivation in India" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS12382 vs VCS VCS4032", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Withdrawn", "Methodology: Not listed in A vs AMS-III.AU. Methane emission reduction by adjusted water management practice in rice耕" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a project by Kosher Climate India Pvt Ltd. in India involving Agriculture / Rice Emission Reductions.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x645d9d4f75ec1dc8710092e213adbd5b7cf7146a4e09ff9d3bf10b1f878f8f0e", "proof": [ "0xf707593f8e17bce028df36caaa03f18edb9883d9949faa7533c77e953f526b1a", "0x0c6bd7c31b65dfd4b786bfd85cb5df03827786bbaa6eb0781e420deed729aa6a", "0xb072ced025cb32ad1f2ab173c63bc700dd4bbacb002c004916f6c9c687981e37", "0xa5db51b2848283654f261a75838afe4771c06a10de8c18b11e6abb671b38fa8f", "0x4f786c84d50cdbfb3e19e9423bb3b9fee90090d4a4cf671b059800b4b8eb1688", "0xc926fff5463964ac1b15fc422c25975a3295227330b079b080923a06acc8b97e" ] }, { "id": "GS23203~VCS2349", "a": "GS23203", "b": "VCS2349", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "Kenya", "screen_score": 0.9, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS23203", "Project Name": "Installation of high efficiency wood burning cookstoves in Kenya", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Listed", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "Other", "Country": "Kenya", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Bridge Carbon Africa Stoves Development Private Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS2349", "Project Name": "Installation of high efficiency wood burning cookstoves in Kenya", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "VM0050 Energy Efficiency and Fuel-Switch Measures in Cookstoves", "Country": "Kenya", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Bridge Carbon Africa Stoves Development Private Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 480466, "Total Credits Retired": 196015, "issued_by_vintage": { "2020": 106, "2021": 24251, "2022": 331705, "2023": 113463, "2024": 8777, "2025": 2164 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Installation of high efficiency wood burning cookstoves in Kenya", "value_b": "Installation of high efficiency wood burning cookstoves in Kenya" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Bridge Carbon Africa Stoves Development Private Limited", "value_b": "Bridge Carbon Africa Stoves Development Private Limited" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "Kenya / None / None", "value_b": "Kenya / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS23203 vs VCS VCS2349", "Methodology: Other vs VM0050 Energy Efficiency and Fuel-Switch Measures in Cookstoves", "Status: Listed vs Registered", "Credits issued by vintage: none vs 2020:106, 2021:24251, 2022:331705, 2023:113463, 2024:8777, 2025:2164" ], "reason": "Both listings share the same name, developer, country, and scope/type for the installation of high efficiency wood burning cookstoves in Kenya.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x317b24b0d4239ce74cae33f51792cf785da1718c9461ae885449e1b426fd2742", "proof": [ "0xe73a205bf0fc0bcef4a01993b87a772e1cf6429fca12758abea08b1b9e981cce", "0x720e013cc54d00dfc4f1ace50c4998d19b894d06e431c164648c072b07af91a9", "0xe072fdd6d706d2be7ec7f70edf6691b55c32df1cbecc6820dd1cbd89576255db", "0xa5db51b2848283654f261a75838afe4771c06a10de8c18b11e6abb671b38fa8f", "0x4f786c84d50cdbfb3e19e9423bb3b9fee90090d4a4cf671b059800b4b8eb1688", "0xc926fff5463964ac1b15fc422c25975a3295227330b079b080923a06acc8b97e" ] }, { "id": "GS23207~VCS2522", "a": "GS23207", "b": "VCS2522", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "Thailand", "screen_score": 0.9, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS23207", "Project Name": "Installation of high efficiency wood burning cookstoves in Thailand", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Listed", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "Other", "Country": "Thailand", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Bridge Carbon SGT Asia Stoves Private Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS2522", "Project Name": "Installation of high efficiency wood burning cookstoves in Thailand", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "VMR0006 Energy Efficiency and Fuel Switch Measures in Thermal Applications", "Country": "Thailand", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Bridge Carbon SGT Asia Stoves Private Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 217099, "Total Credits Retired": 117111, "issued_by_vintage": { "2021": 10022, "2022": 207077 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Installation of high efficiency wood burning cookstoves in Thailand", "value_b": "Installation of high efficiency wood burning cookstoves in Thailand" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Bridge Carbon SGT Asia Stoves Private Limited", "value_b": "Bridge Carbon SGT Asia Stoves Private Limited" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "Thailand / None / None", "value_b": "Thailand / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS23207 vs VCS VCS2522", "Methodology: Other vs VMR0006 Energy Efficiency and Fuel Switch Measures in Thermal Applications", "Status: Listed vs Registered", "Credits issued by vintage: none vs 2021:10022, 2022:207077" ], "reason": "Both listings share the same Name, Developer, Country / State / Site, and Scope / Type.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xe73a205bf0fc0bcef4a01993b87a772e1cf6429fca12758abea08b1b9e981cce", "proof": [ "0x317b24b0d4239ce74cae33f51792cf785da1718c9461ae885449e1b426fd2742", "0x720e013cc54d00dfc4f1ace50c4998d19b894d06e431c164648c072b07af91a9", "0xe072fdd6d706d2be7ec7f70edf6691b55c32df1cbecc6820dd1cbd89576255db", "0xa5db51b2848283654f261a75838afe4771c06a10de8c18b11e6abb671b38fa8f", "0x4f786c84d50cdbfb3e19e9423bb3b9fee90090d4a4cf671b059800b4b8eb1688", "0xc926fff5463964ac1b15fc422c25975a3295227330b079b080923a06acc8b97e" ] }, { "id": "GS23339~VCS3881", "a": "GS23339", "b": "VCS3881", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "Togo", "screen_score": 0.9, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS23339", "Project Name": "Empowering Communities Through Improved Cookstoves", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Listed", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": null, "Country": "Togo", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Carbon Kind Ltd", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS3881", "Project Name": "EMPOWERING COMMUNITIES THROUGH IMPROVED COOKSTOVES", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Withdrawn", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "VMR0006 Energy Efficiency and Fuel Switch Measures in Thermal Applications", "Country": "Togo", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Carbon Kind Ltd", "Total Credits Issued": 3671, "Total Credits Retired": 3671, "issued_by_vintage": { "2023": 2129, "2024": 1542 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Carbon Kind Ltd", "value_b": "Carbon Kind Ltd" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "Togo / None / None", "value_b": "Togo / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" }, { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Empowering Communities Through Improved Cookstoves", "value_b": "EMPOWERING COMMUNITIES THROUGH IMPROVED COOKSTOVES" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS23339 vs VCS VCS3881", "Status: Listed vs Withdrawn", "Credits issued by vintage: none vs 2023:2129, 2024:1542", "Methodology: [Missing] vs VMR0006 Energy Efficiency and Fuel Switch Measures in Thermal Applications" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a project by Carbon Kind Ltd in Togo with the scope of Household & Community / Cookstoves.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x38f086ee85d92fc31528f6a3b58758144592fe9b077684f7c9aa7115a6ae2bcb", "proof": [ "0xad576ddfb446626bc32ba6beba7c9bfc29e60aba821e99a1752d44767e5e8ff3", "0x924d8a439f27eb8ca099d1ff88aaf42181521b58fd34f6edb73f4daf87912d77", "0xe072fdd6d706d2be7ec7f70edf6691b55c32df1cbecc6820dd1cbd89576255db", "0xa5db51b2848283654f261a75838afe4771c06a10de8c18b11e6abb671b38fa8f", "0x4f786c84d50cdbfb3e19e9423bb3b9fee90090d4a4cf671b059800b4b8eb1688", "0xc926fff5463964ac1b15fc422c25975a3295227330b079b080923a06acc8b97e" ] }, { "id": "GS23204~VCS2350", "a": "GS23204", "b": "VCS2350", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "Uganda", "screen_score": 0.9, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS23204", "Project Name": "Installation of high efficiency wood burning cookstoves in Uganda", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Listed", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "Other", "Country": "Uganda", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Bridge Carbon Africa Stoves Development Private Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS2350", "Project Name": "Installation of high efficiency wood burning cookstoves in Uganda", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "VMR0006 Energy Efficiency and Fuel Switch Measures in Thermal Applications", "Country": "Uganda", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Bridge Carbon Africa Stoves Development Private Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 31545, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2021": 95, "2022": 31450 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Installation of high efficiency wood burning cookstoves in Uganda", "value_b": "Installation of high efficiency wood burning cookstoves in Uganda" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Bridge Carbon Africa Stoves Development Private Limited", "value_b": "Bridge Carbon Africa Stoves Development Private Limited" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "Uganda / None / None", "value_b": "Uganda / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS23204 vs VCS VCS2350", "Methodology: Other vs VMR0006 Energy Efficiency and Fuel Switch Measures in Thermal Applications", "Status: Listed vs Registered", "Credits issued by vintage: none vs 2021:95, 2022:31450" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a project named 'Installation of high efficiency wood burning cookstoves in Uganda' developed by 'Bridge Carbon Africa Stoves Development Private Limited' in 'Uganda / None / None'.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xad576ddfb446626bc32ba6beba7c9bfc29e60aba821e99a1752d44767e5e8ff3", "proof": [ "0x38f086ee85d92fc31528f6a3b58758144592fe9b077684f7c9aa7115a6ae2bcb", "0x924d8a439f27eb8ca099d1ff88aaf42181521b58fd34f6edb73f4daf87912d77", "0xe072fdd6d706d2be7ec7f70edf6691b55c32df1cbecc6820dd1cbd89576255db", "0xa5db51b2848283654f261a75838afe4771c06a10de8c18b11e6abb671b38fa8f", "0x4f786c84d50cdbfb3e19e9423bb3b9fee90090d4a4cf671b059800b4b8eb1688", "0xc926fff5463964ac1b15fc422c25975a3295227330b079b080923a06acc8b97e" ] }, { "id": "GS23208~VCS2523", "a": "GS23208", "b": "VCS2523", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "Viet Nam", "screen_score": 0.9, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS23208", "Project Name": "Installation of high efficiency wood burning cookstoves in Vietnam", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Listed", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "Other", "Country": "Viet Nam", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Bridge Carbon SGT Asia Stoves Private Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS2523", "Project Name": "Installation of high efficiency wood burning cookstoves in Vietnam", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "VMR0006 Energy Efficiency and Fuel Switch Measures in Thermal Applications", "Country": "Viet Nam", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Bridge Carbon SGT Asia Stoves Private Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 206369, "Total Credits Retired": 121180, "issued_by_vintage": { "2021": 3138, "2022": 203231 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Installation of high efficiency wood burning cookstoves in Vietnam", "value_b": "Installation of high efficiency wood burning cookstoves in Vietnam" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Bridge Carbon SGT Asia Stoves Private Limited", "value_b": "Bridge Carbon SGT Asia Stoves Private Limited" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "Viet Nam / None / None", "value_b": "Viet Nam / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" }, { "field": "Status", "value_a": "Listed", "value_b": "Registered" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS23208 vs VCS VCS2523", "Methodology: Other vs VMR0006 Energy Efficiency and Fuel Switch Measures in Thermal Applications", "Credits issued by vintage: none vs 2021:3138, 2022:203231" ], "reason": "Both listings share the same Name, Developer, Country / State / Site, and Scope / Type.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x8b2c9caec7bfb73a12f1b40831823820a5ca4c186bff3ae5c8c254994c5ce9f6", "proof": [ "0xfd8f02e430737e2d048a68c5cee35f5a8f07cb48bd853b7ea3fc73d7c1c95cb5", "0xad3f7985aa2f9a7cb4c2e92909f1ecc9cdcf1f92e8e88127296ceebfab3d626e", "0xf14a6abdd6afa07f2293f566a8a239e82ef2bfadac8157322204571eaa8489e3", "0x0d84f8990d1fad3cceb191abde54fe4ae58a35797305070430a464b068dcf0ee", "0x4f786c84d50cdbfb3e19e9423bb3b9fee90090d4a4cf671b059800b4b8eb1688", "0xc926fff5463964ac1b15fc422c25975a3295227330b079b080923a06acc8b97e" ] }, { "id": "GS6091~VCS1307", "a": "GS6091", "b": "VCS1307", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.85, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS6091", "Project Name": "Biomass Based Steam Generation Plant by Farmgate Agro Milch Private Limited", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Listed", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Biomass", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.C. Thermal energy production with or without electricity", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Farmgate Agro Milch Private Limited \"GSF\"", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1307", "Project Name": "Biomass Based Steam Generation Plant Farmgate Agro Milch", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Under validation", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Biomass", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.C. Thermal energy production with or without electricity", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "FARMGATE AGRO MILCH PRIVATE LIMITED", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Biomass", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Biomass" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "AMS-I.C. Thermal energy production with or without electricity", "value_b": "AMS-I.C. Thermal energy production with or without electricity" }, { "field": "Credits issued by vintage", "value_a": "none", "value_b": "none" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Farmgate Agro Milch Private Limited \"GSF\"", "value_b": "FARMGATE AGRO MILCH PRIVATE LIMITED" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS6091 vs VCS VCS1307", "Name: Biomass Based Steam Generation Plant by Farmgate Agro Milch Private Limited vs Biomass Based Steam Generation Farm" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a Biomass Renewable Energy project in India using the AMS-I.C. Thermal energy production methodology developed by Farmgate Agro Milch Private Limited.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xfd8f02e430737e2d048a68c5cee35f5a8f07cb48bd853b7ea3fc73d7c1c95cb5", "proof": [ "0x8b2c9caec7bfb73a12f1b40831823820a5ca4c186bff3ae5c8c254994c5ce9f6", "0xad3f7985aa2f9a7cb4c2e92909f1ecc9cdcf1f92e8e88127296ceebfab3d626e", "0xf14a6abdd6afa07f2293f566a8a239e82ef2bfadac8157322204571eaa8489e3", "0x0d84f8990d1fad3cceb191abde54fe4ae58a35797305070430a464b068dcf0ee", "0x4f786c84d50cdbfb3e19e9423bb3b9fee90090d4a4cf671b059800b4b8eb1688", "0xc926fff5463964ac1b15fc422c25975a3295227330b079b080923a06acc8b97e" ] }, { "id": "GS12319~VCS4129", "a": "GS12319", "b": "VCS4129", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.85, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS12319", "Project Name": "Project Sathya Improved Cookstoves and Livelihood", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Design", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": null, "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "CARBON IMPACT CAPITAL PTE. LTD.", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS4129", "Project Name": "Project Sathya Improved Cookstoves and Livelihood", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Withdrawn", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "VMR0006 Energy Efficiency and Fuel Switch Measures in Thermal Applications", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Carbon Impact Capital", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Project Sathya Improved Cookstoves and Livelihood", "value_b": "Project Sathya Improved Cookstoves and Livelihood" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" }, { "field": "Credits issued by vintage", "value_a": "none", "value_b": "none" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "CARBON IMPACT CAPITAL PTE. LTD.", "value_b": "Carbon Impact Capital" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS12319 vs VCS VCS4129", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Design vs Withdrawn", "Methodology: Not listed in A vs VMR0006 Energy Efficiency and Fuel Switch Measures in Thermal Applications" ], "reason": "Both listings share the same Name, Country / State / Site, Scope / Type, and Developer.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x85bbb642ac7c204bd17c272bbe871f06f271cf3325e48cbc8fb1ca535f4d1a26", "proof": [ "0x1e3595f20778057611d1dd884e9b549a61d27548bed1daf950c379414747f18a", "0xacf03ab20bd17304b388b1b131613e2ee396179bc6b294d4a5d125ce92d5c575", "0xf14a6abdd6afa07f2293f566a8a239e82ef2bfadac8157322204571eaa8489e3", "0x0d84f8990d1fad3cceb191abde54fe4ae58a35797305070430a464b068dcf0ee", "0x4f786c84d50cdbfb3e19e9423bb3b9fee90090d4a4cf671b059800b4b8eb1688", "0xc926fff5463964ac1b15fc422c25975a3295227330b079b080923a06acc8b97e" ] }, { "id": "GS828~VCS831", "a": "GS828", "b": "VCS831", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "Nicaragua", "screen_score": 0.85, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.95, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS828", "Project Name": "Amayo Phase II Wind Power Project", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": null, "Country": "Nicaragua", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Consorcio Eólico Amayo S.A.", "Total Credits Issued": 653375, "Total Credits Retired": 169887, "issued_by_vintage": { "2014": 62627, "2015": 59954, "2016": 65418, "2017": 57524, "2018": 83102, "2019": 122594, "2020": 52219, "2021": 54167, "2022": 48764, "2023": 47006 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS831", "Project Name": "Amayo Phase II Wind Power Project", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Late to verify", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "Nicaragua", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Consorcio Eólico Amayo (Fase II) S.A.", "Total Credits Issued": 77544, "Total Credits Retired": 77444, "issued_by_vintage": { "2011": 77544 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Amayo Phase II Wind Power Project", "value_b": "Amayo Phase II Wind Power Project" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "Nicaragua / None / None", "value_b": "Nicaragua / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS828 vs VCS VCS831", "Developer: Consorcio Eólico Amayo S.A. vs Consorcio Eólico Amayo (Fase II) S.A.", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Late to verify", "Credits issued by vintage: 2014-2023 vs 2011" ], "reason": "Both listings describe the Amayo Phase II Wind Power Project located in Nicaragua under the Scope / Type of Renewable Energy / Wind.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x1e3595f20778057611d1dd884e9b549a61d27548bed1daf950c379414747f18a", "proof": [ "0x85bbb642ac7c204bd17c272bbe871f06f271cf3325e48cbc8fb1ca535f4d1a26", "0xacf03ab20bd17304b388b1b131613e2ee396179bc6b294d4a5d125ce92d5c575", "0xf14a6abdd6afa07f2293f566a8a239e82ef2bfadac8157322204571eaa8489e3", "0x0d84f8990d1fad3cceb191abde54fe4ae58a35797305070430a464b068dcf0ee", "0x4f786c84d50cdbfb3e19e9423bb3b9fee90090d4a4cf671b059800b4b8eb1688", "0xc926fff5463964ac1b15fc422c25975a3295227330b079b080923a06acc8b97e" ] }, { "id": "ACR0873~CAR1616", "a": "ACR0873", "b": "CAR1616", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.8477, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0873", "Project Name": "Mississippi River Islands Forest Conservation Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Active: Registered", "Scope": "Forestry & Land Use", "Type": "Improved Forest Management", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACR Improved Forest Management (IFM) on Non-Federal U.S. Forestlands", "Country": "United States", "State": "KENTUCKY, ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Island 8, Wolf Island Bar, Burnham Island", "Project Developer": "U.S. Venture, Inc.", "Total Credits Issued": 462802, "Total Credits Retired": 45416, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 53510, "2023": 180417, "2024": 156604, "2025": 72271 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR1616", "Project Name": "Mississippi River Islands Forest Conservation Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Forestry & Land Use", "Type": "Avoided Forest Conversion", "Methodology / Protocol": "CAR U.S. Forest Protocol", "Country": "United States", "State": "KENTUCKY", "Project Site Location": "Fulton County, KY; Hickman County, KY; Alexander County, IL", "Project Developer": "U.S. Venture, Inc.", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Mississippi River Islands Forest Conservation Project", "value_b": "Mississippi River Islands Forest Conservation Project" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "U.S. Venture, Inc.", "value_b": "U.S. Venture, Inc." }, { "field": "Country", "value_a": "United States", "value_b": "United States" }, { "field": "State", "value_a": "KENTUCKY, ILLINOIS", "value_b": "KENTUCKY" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR0873 vs CAR CAR1616", "Scope / Type: Improved Forest Management vs Avoided Forest Conversion", "Methodology: ACR Improved Forest Management (IFM) on Non-Federal U.S. Forestlands vs CAR U.S. Forest Protocol", "Status: Active: Registered vs Completed" ], "reason": "Both listings describe the Mississippi River Islands Forest Conservation Project developed by U.S. Venture, Inc. in the United States.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xf14a6abdd6afa07f2293f566a8a239e82ef2bfadac8157322204571eaa8489e3", "proof": [ "0x588fa3b1d8e3dcd791546362c28a9e8d329a966d56b6b0035afdf03e8debd1c3", "0x0d84f8990d1fad3cceb191abde54fe4ae58a35797305070430a464b068dcf0ee", "0x4f786c84d50cdbfb3e19e9423bb3b9fee90090d4a4cf671b059800b4b8eb1688", "0xc926fff5463964ac1b15fc422c25975a3295227330b079b080923a06acc8b97e" ] } ], "review": [ { "id": "ACR0172~CAR1000", "a": "ACR0172", "b": "CAR1000", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.9727, "name_sim": 0.9503, "overlap_vintages": [ 2013 ], "overlap_volume": 55996, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0172", "Project Name": "EOS ARB ODS 2013-2", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "Country": "United States", "State": "ARKANSAS", "Project Site Location": "El Dorado", "Project Developer": "EOS Climate Inc", "Total Credits Issued": 55996, "Total Credits Retired": 55996, "issued_by_vintage": { "2013": 55996 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR1000", "Project Name": "EOS ARB ODS 2013-5", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "Country": "United States", "State": "ARKANSAS", "Project Site Location": "El Dorado", "Project Developer": "EOS Climate Inc.", "Total Credits Issued": 126155, "Total Credits Retired": 126155, "issued_by_vintage": { "2013": 126155 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "no", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "EOS Climate Inc", "value_b": "EOS Climate Inc." }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / ARKANSAS / El Dorado", "value_b": "United States / ARKANSAS / El Dorado" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "value_b": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances起こ", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances起こ" }, { "field": "Status", "value_a": "Completed", "value_b": "Completed" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR0172 vs CAR CAR1000", "Name: EOS ARB ODS 2013-2 vs EOS ARB ODS 2013-5", "Credits issued by vintage: 2013:55996 vs 2013:126155" ], "reason": "The listings have different Registry / IDs, Names, and Credits issued by vintage.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR0181~CAR992", "a": "ACR0181", "b": "CAR992", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.9718, "name_sim": 0.9488, "overlap_vintages": [ 2013 ], "overlap_volume": 51864, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0181", "Project Name": "EOS ARB ODS 2013-6", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "Country": "United States", "State": "ARKANSAS", "Project Site Location": "El Dorado", "Project Developer": "EOS Climate Inc", "Total Credits Issued": 51864, "Total Credits Retired": 51864, "issued_by_vintage": { "2013": 51864 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR992", "Project Name": "EOS ARB ODS 2013-1", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "Country": "United States", "State": "ARKANSAS", "Project Site Location": "El Dorado", "Project Developer": "EOS Climate Inc.", "Total Credits Issued": 107542, "Total Credits Retired": 107542, "issued_by_vintage": { "2013": 107542 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "no", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "EOS Climate Inc", "value_b": "EOS Climate Inc." }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / ARKANSAS / El Dorado", "value_b": "United States / ARKANSAS / El Dorado" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "value_b": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances起こ", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances起こ" }, { "field": "Status", "value_a": "Completed", "value_b": "Completed" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR0181 vs CAR CAR992", "Name: EOS ARB ODS 2013-6 vs EOS ARB ODS 2013-1", "Credits issued by vintage: 2013:51864 vs 2013:107542" ], "reason": "The listings have different Registry / IDs, Names, and Credits issued by vintage.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR0172~CAR1021", "a": "ACR0172", "b": "CAR1021", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.9693, "name_sim": 0.9441, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0172", "Project Name": "EOS ARB ODS 2013-2", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "Country": "United States", "State": "ARKANSAS", "Project Site Location": "El Dorado", "Project Developer": "EOS Climate Inc", "Total Credits Issued": 55996, "Total Credits Retired": 55996, "issued_by_vintage": { "2013": 55996 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR1021", "Project Name": "EOS ARB ODS 2013-8", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "Country": "United States", "State": "ARKANSAS", "Project Site Location": "El Dorado", "Project Developer": "EOS Climate Inc.", "Total Credits Issued": 67490, "Total Credits Retired": 67490, "issued_by_vintage": { "2014": 67490 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "no", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "EOS Climate Inc", "value_b": "EOS Climate Inc." }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / ARKANSAS / El Dorado", "value_b": "United States / ARKANSAS / El Dorado" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "value_b": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances起こ", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances起こ" }, { "field": "Status", "value_a": "Completed", "value_b": "Completed" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR0172 vs CAR CAR1021", "Name: EOS ARB ODS 2013-2 vs EOS ARB ODS 2013-8", "Credits issued by vintage: 2013:55996 vs 2014:67490" ], "reason": "The listings have different Registry / IDs, Names, and Credits issued by vintage.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR0234~CAR1582", "a": "ACR0234", "b": "CAR1582", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.9667, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [ 2020 ], "overlap_volume": 718, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0234", "Project Name": "Alliance Dairy", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Terminated", "Scope": "Agriculture", "Type": "Manure Methane Digester", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Capturing and Destroying Methane from Manure Management Systems", "Country": "United States", "State": "FLORIDA", "Project Site Location": "Trenton", "Project Developer": "3Degrees Group, Inc.", "Total Credits Issued": 84219, "Total Credits Retired": 84219, "issued_by_vintage": { "2015": 12382, "2016": 14787, "2017": 14054, "2018": 15864, "2019": 10809, "2020": 16323 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR1582", "Project Name": "Alliance Dairy", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Agriculture", "Type": "Manure Methane Digester", "Methodology / Protocol": "CAR U.S. Livestock Protocol", "Country": "United States", "State": "FLORIDA", "Project Site Location": "Trenton, FL", "Project Developer": "3Degrees Group, Inc", "Total Credits Issued": 33665, "Total Credits Retired": 12978, "issued_by_vintage": { "2020": 718, "2021": 21989, "2022": 10958 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "no", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Alliance Dairy", "value_b": "Alliance Dairy" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "3Degrees Group, Inc.", "value_b": "3Degrees Group, Inc" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / FLORIDA / Trenton", "value_b": "United States / FLORIDA / Trenton, FL" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Agriculture / Manure Methane Digester", "value_b": "Agriculture / Manure Methane Digester" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR0234 vs CAR CAR1582", "Methodology: ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Capturing and Destroying Methane from Manure Management Systems vs CAR U.S.", "- Livestock Protocol", "Status: Terminated vs Registered" ], "reason": "The listings have different Registry / IDs, Methodologies, and Statuses.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false }, { "id": "ACR0193~CAR1021", "a": "ACR0193", "b": "CAR1021", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.9604, "name_sim": 0.928, "overlap_vintages": [ 2014 ], "overlap_volume": 67490, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0193", "Project Name": "EOS ARB ODS 2013-7", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "Country": "United States", "State": "ARKANSAS", "Project Site Location": "El Dorado", "Project Developer": "EOS Climate Inc", "Total Credits Issued": 84418, "Total Credits Retired": 84418, "issued_by_vintage": { "2014": 84418 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR1021", "Project Name": "EOS ARB ODS 2013-8", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "Country": "United States", "State": "ARKANSAS", "Project Site Location": "El Dorado", "Project Developer": "EOS Climate Inc.", "Total Credits Issued": 67490, "Total Credits Retired": 67490, "issued_by_vintage": { "2014": 67490 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "no", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "EOS Climate Inc", "value_b": "EOS Climate Inc." }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / ARKANSAS / El Dorado", "value_b": "United States / ARKANSAS / El Dorado" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "value_b": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances起こ", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances起こ" }, { "field": "Status", "value_a": "Completed", "value_b": "Completed" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR0193 vs CAR CAR1021", "Name: EOS ARB ODS 2013-7 vs EOS ARB ODS 2013-8", "Credits issued by vintage: 2014:84418 vs 2014:67490" ], "reason": "The listings have different Registry / IDs, Names, and Credits issued by vintage.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR0176~CAR1029", "a": "ACR0176", "b": "CAR1029", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.9287, "name_sim": 0.9159, "overlap_vintages": [ 2013 ], "overlap_volume": 113438, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0176", "Project Name": "ECC ODS Destruction 2013", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "Country": "United States", "State": "ARKANSAS", "Project Site Location": "El Dorado", "Project Developer": "Environmental Credit Corp.", "Total Credits Issued": 255227, "Total Credits Retired": 254284, "issued_by_vintage": { "2013": 255227 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR1029", "Project Name": "ECC ODS Destruction 11-2013", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "Country": "United States", "State": "ARKANSAS", "Project Site Location": "El Dorado, AR", "Project Developer": "Environmental Credit Corp.", "Total Credits Issued": 113438, "Total Credits Retired": 113438, "issued_by_vintage": { "2013": 113438 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "no", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Environmental Credit Corp.", "value_b": "Environmental Credit Corp." }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / ARKANSAS / El Dorado", "value_b": "United States / ARKANSAS / El Dorado, AR" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "value_b": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances" }, { "field": "Status", "value_a": "Completed", "value_b": "Completed" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR0176 vs CAR CAR1029", "Name: ECC ODS Destruction 2013 vs ECC ODS Destruction 11-2013", "Credits issued by vintage: 2013:255227 vs 2013:113438" ], "reason": "The listings have different Registry / IDs, Names, and Credits issued by vintage.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR0675~CAR2171", "a": "ACR0675", "b": "CAR2171", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.92, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0675", "Project Name": "Heilwood Mine Methane Incineration Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "PENNSYLVANIA", "Project Site Location": "Heilwood", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Energy LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 284707, "Total Credits Retired": 111933, "issued_by_vintage": { "2021": 64387, "2022": 65587, "2023": 66930, "2024": 87803 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2171", "Project Name": "Heilwood Mine Methane Incineration Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "WEST VIRGINIA", "Project Site Location": "Near Heilwood", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Energy, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 27792, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 27792 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Heilwood Mine Methane Incineration Project", "value_b": "Heilwood Mine Methane Incineration Project" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Energy LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Energy, LLC" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR0675 vs CAR CAR2171", "Country / State / Site: United States / PENNSYLVANIA / Heilwood vs United States / WEST VIRGINIA / Near Heilwood", "Status: Transferred ARB Project vs Registered", "Credits issued by vintage: 2021:64387, 2022:65587, 2023:66930, 2024:87803 vs 2025:27792" ], "reason": "The listings share the same project name, developer, scope, and methodology, but differ in registry ID, state location, and credit vintages.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false }, { "id": "ACR0372~CAR990", "a": "ACR0372", "b": "CAR990", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.8827, "name_sim": 0.7868, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0372", "Project Name": "EOS 2013 Domestic (EOS ACR 372)", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "CAR U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Protocol", "Country": "United States", "State": "ARKANSAS", "Project Site Location": "El Dorado", "Project Developer": "EOS Climate Inc", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR990", "Project Name": "EOS 2013 Domestic", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "Country": "United States", "State": "ARKANSAS", "Project Site Location": "El Dorado", "Project Developer": "EOS Climate Inc.", "Total Credits Issued": 366749, "Total Credits Retired": 366749, "issued_by_vintage": { "2013": 325668, "2014": 41081 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "EOS Climate Inc", "value_b": "EOS Climate Inc." }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / ARKANSAS / El Dorado", "value_b": "United States / ARKANSAS / El Dorado" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "value_b": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction" }, { "field": "Status", "value_a": "Completed", "value_b": "Completed" }, { "field": "Name", "value_a": "EOS 2013 Domestic (EOS ACR 372)", "value_b": "EOS 2013 Domestic" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR0372 vs CAR CAR990", "Methodology: CAR U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Protocol vs ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone杖_", "Credits issued by vintage: none vs 2013:325668, 2014:41081", "Description: [Present in A, missing in B]" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a project by EOS Climate Inc. in El Dorado, Arkansas, involving Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction with a Completed status.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR0578~CAR2113", "a": "ACR0578", "b": "CAR2113", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.8738, "name_sim": 0.7705, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0578", "Project Name": "New Era Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Galatia", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 461227, "Total Credits Retired": 82012, "issued_by_vintage": { "2021": 94880, "2022": 77171, "2023": 68914, "2024": 220262 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2113", "Project Name": "New Future Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Galatia", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment,LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 73186, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 73186 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "no", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Environment,LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / ILLINOIS / Galatia", "value_b": "United States / ILLINOIS / Galatia" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR0578 vs CAR CAR2113", "Name: New Era Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project vs New Future Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Status: Transferred ARB Project vs Registered", "Credits issued by vintage: 2021:94880, 2022:77171, 2023:68914, 2024:220262 vs 2025:73186" ], "reason": "The listings have different Registry / IDs, Names, Statuses, and Credits issued by vintage.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR0669~CAR2092", "a": "ACR0669", "b": "CAR2092", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.8738, "name_sim": 0.7705, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0669", "Project Name": "New Future Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Galatia", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 174700, "Total Credits Retired": 112158, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 62598, "2023": 49560, "2024": 62542 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2092", "Project Name": "New Era Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Galatia", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment,LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 220149, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 220149 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Environment,LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / ILLINOIS / Galatia", "value_b": "United States / ILLINOIS / Galatia" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR0669 vs CAR CAR2092", "Name: New Future Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project vs New Era Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Status: Transferred ARB Project vs Registered", "Credits issued by vintage: 2022:62598, 2023:49560, 2024:62542 vs 2025:220149" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a Mine Methane Capture project in Galatia, Illinois, developed by Keyrock Environment LLC using the ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS12292~VCS4229", "a": "GS12292", "b": "VCS4229", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.8569, "name_sim": 0.9216, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS12292", "Project Name": "Renew Sakhi Improved Cookstove", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Design", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": null, "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Renew Power Synergy Private Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS4229", "Project Name": "RENEW SAKHI - IMPROVED COOKSTOVES - 01", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "VMR0006 Energy Efficiency and Fuel Switch Measures in Thermal Applications", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "ReNew Power Synergy Private Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 205769, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2023": 114100, "2024": 91669 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Renew Power Synergy Private Limited", "value_b": "ReNew Power Synergy Private Limited" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" }, { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Renew Sakhi Improved Cookstove", "value_b": "RENEW SAKHI - IMPROVED COOKSTOVES - 01" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS12292 vs VCS VCS4229", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Design vs Registered", "Credits issued by vintage: none vs 2023:114100, 2024:91669", "Methodology: [Not listed in A] vs VMR0006 Energy Efficiency and Fuel Switch Measures in Thermal Applications" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a cookstove project in India developed by ReNew Power Synergy Private Limited.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR0644~CAR2254", "a": "ACR0644", "b": "CAR2254", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.8545, "name_sim": 0.8718, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0644", "Project Name": "Willow Lake Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Equality", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 276175, "Total Credits Retired": 88822, "issued_by_vintage": { "2021": 33491, "2022": 73501, "2023": 97223, "2024": 71960 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2254", "Project Name": "Willow Lake Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Eldorado, IL", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment,LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 54283, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 54283 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Environment,LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / ILLINOIS", "value_b": "United States / ILLINOIS" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR0644 vs CAR CAR2254", "Name: Willow Lake Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project vs Willow Lake Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Site: Equality vs Eldorado, IL", "Status: Transferred ARB Project vs Registered" ], "reason": "While both listings share the same developer, methodology, and scope, they differ in Registry ID, project name, specific site location, and status.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false }, { "id": "GS7621~VCS701", "a": "GS7621", "b": "VCS701", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.8521, "name_sim": 0.9129, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS7621", "Project Name": "50.6 MW Wind Power Project in Gujarat by Powerica Limited", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": null, "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Powerica Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 262301, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2023": 132445, "2024": 129856 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS701", "Project Name": "Wind power project at Gujarat by Powerica Limited", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "POWERICA LIMITED", "Total Credits Issued": 244452, "Total Credits Retired": 244452, "issued_by_vintage": { "2010": 16388, "2013": 23415, "2014": 22222, "2015": 24722, "2016": 24079, "2017": 25163, "2018": 24926, "2019": 23052, "2020": 18915, "2021": 21273, "2022": 20297 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Powerica Limited", "value_b": "POWERICA LIMITED" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" }, { "field": "Name", "value_a": "50.6 MW Wind Power Project in Gujarat by Powerica Limited", "value_b": "Wind power project at Gujarat by Powerica Limited" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS7621 vs VCS VCS701", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Registered", "Credits issued by vintage: 2023:132445, 2024:129856 vs 2010:16388, 2013:23415, 2014:22222, 2015:24722, 2016:24079, 2017:", "25163, 2018:24926, 2019:23052, 2020:18915, 2021:21273, 2022:20297" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a Wind power project in India developed by Powerica Limited.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR0736~CAR2157", "a": "ACR0736", "b": "CAR2157", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.8465, "name_sim": 0.7209, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0736", "Project Name": "Tradewater US - ODS - #1", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACR Destruction of Ozone Depleting Substances and High-GWP Foam", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 31818, "Total Credits Retired": 30366, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 31818 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2157", "Project Name": "Tradewater ODS 64", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozone Depleting Substances Projects (ODS)", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 51771, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 51771 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "no", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Tradewater, LLC", "value_b": "Tradewater LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool", "value_b": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "value_b": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR0736 vs CAR CAR2157", "Name: Tradewater US - ODS - #1 vs Tradewater ODS 64", "Methodology: ACR Destruction of Ozone Depleting Substances and High-GWP Foam vs ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozonexml", "Credits issued by vintage: 2022:31818 vs 2025:51771" ], "reason": "The listings have different Registry / IDs, Names, Methodologies, and Credits issued by vintage.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR0758~CAR2157", "a": "ACR0758", "b": "CAR2157", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.8457, "name_sim": 0.7194, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0758", "Project Name": "Tradewater US - ODS - #2", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACR Destruction of Ozone Depleting Substances and High-GWP Foam", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 24294, "Total Credits Retired": 24294, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 24294 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2157", "Project Name": "Tradewater ODS 64", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozone Depleting Substances Projects (ODS)", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 51771, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 51771 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "no", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Tradewater, LLC", "value_b": "Tradewater LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool", "value_b": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "value_b": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR0758 vs CAR CAR2157", "Name: Tradewater US - ODS - #2 vs Tradewater ODS 64", "Methodology: ACR Destruction of Ozone Depleting Substances and High-GWP Foam vs ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozonexml", "Credits issued by vintage: 2022:24294 vs 2025:51771" ], "reason": "The listings have different Registry / IDs, Names, Methodologies, and Credits issued by vintage.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR0736~CAR2153", "a": "ACR0736", "b": "CAR2153", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.8416, "name_sim": 0.712, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0736", "Project Name": "Tradewater US - ODS - #1", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACR Destruction of Ozone Depleting Substances and High-GWP Foam", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 31818, "Total Credits Retired": 30366, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 31818 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2153", "Project Name": "Tradewater ODS 62", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozone Depleting Substances Projects (ODS)", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 315246, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 315246 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "no", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Tradewater, LLC", "value_b": "Tradewater LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool", "value_b": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "value_b": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR0736 vs CAR CAR2153", "Name: Tradewater US - ODS - #1 vs Tradewater ODS 62", "Methodology: ACR Destruction of Ozone Depleting Substances and High-GWP Foam vs ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozonexml", "Credits issued by vintage: 2022:31818 vs 2025:315246" ], "reason": "The listings have different Registry / IDs, Names, Methodologies, and Credits issued by vintage.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR0736~CAR2312", "a": "ACR0736", "b": "CAR2312", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.8416, "name_sim": 0.712, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0736", "Project Name": "Tradewater US - ODS - #1", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACR Destruction of Ozone Depleting Substances and High-GWP Foam", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 31818, "Total Credits Retired": 30366, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 31818 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2312", "Project Name": "Tradewater ODS 68", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Listed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozone Depleting Substances Projects (ODS)", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Tradewater, LLC", "value_b": "Tradewater LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool", "value_b": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "value_b": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR0736 vs CAR CAR2312", "Name: Tradewater US - ODS - #1 vs Tradewater ODS 68", "Methodology: ACR Destruction of Ozone Depleting Substances and High-GWP Foam vs ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozonexml", "Status: Completed vs Listed" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a project developed by Tradewater LLC in East Liverpool, Ohio, involving Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR0758~CAR2153", "a": "ACR0758", "b": "CAR2153", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.8408, "name_sim": 0.7105, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0758", "Project Name": "Tradewater US - ODS - #2", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACR Destruction of Ozone Depleting Substances and High-GWP Foam", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 24294, "Total Credits Retired": 24294, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 24294 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2153", "Project Name": "Tradewater ODS 62", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozone Depleting Substances Projects (ODS)", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 315246, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 315246 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [], "differences": [], "reason": "", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR0758~CAR2312", "a": "ACR0758", "b": "CAR2312", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.8408, "name_sim": 0.7105, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0758", "Project Name": "Tradewater US - ODS - #2", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACR Destruction of Ozone Depleting Substances and High-GWP Foam", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 24294, "Total Credits Retired": 24294, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 24294 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2312", "Project Name": "Tradewater ODS 68", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Listed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozone Depleting Substances Projects (ODS)", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [], "differences": [], "reason": "", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR0232~CAR402", "a": "ACR0232", "b": "CAR402", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.84, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.95, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0232", "Project Name": "The Dry Creek Dairy Biofactory Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Terminated", "Scope": "Agriculture", "Type": "Manure Methane Digester", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Capturing and Destroying Methane from Manure Management Systems", "Country": "United States", "State": "IDAHO", "Project Site Location": "Hansen", "Project Developer": "Camco Offsets I, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 298204, "Total Credits Retired": 298204, "issued_by_vintage": { "2015": 43254, "2016": 50088, "2017": 55174, "2018": 53275, "2019": 59299, "2020": 37114 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR402", "Project Name": "The Dry Creek Dairy BioFactory® Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Agriculture", "Type": "Manure Methane Digester", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Capturing and Destroying Methane from Manure Management Systems", "Country": "United States", "State": "IDAHO", "Project Site Location": "Hansen", "Project Developer": "Camco International Group, Inc.", "Total Credits Issued": 148563, "Total Credits Retired": 148563, "issued_by_vintage": { "2008": 3792, "2009": 7919, "2010": 41037, "2011": 33024, "2012": 3359, "2013": 29905, "2014": 29527 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [], "differences": [], "reason": "", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false }, { "id": "ACR0736~CAR2152", "a": "ACR0736", "b": "CAR2152", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.8392, "name_sim": 0.7077, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0736", "Project Name": "Tradewater US - ODS - #1", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACR Destruction of Ozone Depleting Substances and High-GWP Foam", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 31818, "Total Credits Retired": 30366, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 31818 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2152", "Project Name": "Tradewater ODS 63", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozone Depleting Substances Projects (ODS)", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 138000, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 138000 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [], "differences": [], "reason": "", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR0736~CAR2257", "a": "ACR0736", "b": "CAR2257", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.8392, "name_sim": 0.7077, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0736", "Project Name": "Tradewater US - ODS - #1", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACR Destruction of Ozone Depleting Substances and High-GWP Foam", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 31818, "Total Credits Retired": 30366, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 31818 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2257", "Project Name": "Tradewater ODS 66", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozone Depleting Substances Projects (ODS)", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 87092, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 87092 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [], "differences": [], "reason": "", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR0736~CAR2283", "a": "ACR0736", "b": "CAR2283", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.8392, "name_sim": 0.7077, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0736", "Project Name": "Tradewater US - ODS - #1", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACR Destruction of Ozone Depleting Substances and High-GWP Foam", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 31818, "Total Credits Retired": 30366, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 31818 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2283", "Project Name": "Tradewater ODS 67", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozone Depleting Substances Projects (ODS)", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 96054, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2026": 96054 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [], "differences": [], "reason": "", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR0736~CAR2314", "a": "ACR0736", "b": "CAR2314", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.8392, "name_sim": 0.7077, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0736", "Project Name": "Tradewater US - ODS - #1", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACR Destruction of Ozone Depleting Substances and High-GWP Foam", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 31818, "Total Credits Retired": 30366, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 31818 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2314", "Project Name": "Tradewater ODS 69", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Listed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozone Depleting Substances Projects (ODS)", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [], "differences": [], "reason": "", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR0758~CAR2152", "a": "ACR0758", "b": "CAR2152", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.8384, "name_sim": 0.7062, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0758", "Project Name": "Tradewater US - ODS - #2", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACR Destruction of Ozone Depleting Substances and High-GWP Foam", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 24294, "Total Credits Retired": 24294, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 24294 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2152", "Project Name": "Tradewater ODS 63", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozone Depleting Substances Projects (ODS)", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 138000, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 138000 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [], "differences": [], "reason": "", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR0758~CAR2257", "a": "ACR0758", "b": "CAR2257", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.8384, "name_sim": 0.7062, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0758", "Project Name": "Tradewater US - ODS - #2", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACR Destruction of Ozone Depleting Substances and High-GWP Foam", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 24294, "Total Credits Retired": 24294, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 24294 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2257", "Project Name": "Tradewater ODS 66", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozone Depleting Substances Projects (ODS)", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 87092, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 87092 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [], "differences": [], "reason": "", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR0758~CAR2283", "a": "ACR0758", "b": "CAR2283", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.8384, "name_sim": 0.7062, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0758", "Project Name": "Tradewater US - ODS - #2", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACR Destruction of Ozone Depleting Substances and High-GWP Foam", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 24294, "Total Credits Retired": 24294, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 24294 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2283", "Project Name": "Tradewater ODS 67", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozone Depleting Substances Projects (ODS)", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 96054, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2026": 96054 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [], "differences": [], "reason": "", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR0758~CAR2314", "a": "ACR0758", "b": "CAR2314", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.8384, "name_sim": 0.7062, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0758", "Project Name": "Tradewater US - ODS - #2", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACR Destruction of Ozone Depleting Substances and High-GWP Foam", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 24294, "Total Credits Retired": 24294, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 24294 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2314", "Project Name": "Tradewater ODS 69", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Listed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozone Depleting Substances Projects (ODS)", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [], "differences": [], "reason": "", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS1307~VCS346", "a": "GS1307", "b": "VCS346", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.8333, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS1307", "Project Name": "Wind power project by GFL in Gudhepanchgani", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Listed", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Gujarat Fluorochemicals Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS346", "Project Name": "Wind power project by GFL in Gudhepanchgani", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Late to verify", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Gujarat Fluorochemicals Limited (GFL)", "Total Credits Issued": 36976, "Total Credits Retired": 36976, "issued_by_vintage": { "2007": 29649, "2008": 7327 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [], "differences": [], "reason": "", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false }, { "id": "GS23142~ISOprj_1K7F70BKD1S04GWB", "a": "GS23142", "b": "ISOprj_1K7F70BKD1S04GWB", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "ISO", "country": "Papua New Guinea", "screen_score": 0.8333, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS23142", "Project Name": "Morobe Markham Reforestation Project", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Listed", "Scope": "Forestry & Land Use", "Type": "Afforestation/Reforestation", "Methodology / Protocol": "GS Methodology for Afforestation/Reforestation GHG Emissions Reduction and Sequestration", "Country": "Papua New Guinea", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Morobe Markham LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "ISOprj_1K7F70BKD1S04GWB", "Project Name": "Morobe Markham Reforestation", "Voluntary Registry": "ISO", "Voluntary Status": "Under validation", "Scope": "Forestry & Land Use", "Type": "Afforestation/Reforestation", "Methodology / Protocol": "Reforestation", "Country": "Papua New Guinea", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Morobe Markham Reforestation", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [], "differences": [], "reason": "", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false }, { "id": "ACR1103~CAR2312", "a": "ACR1103", "b": "CAR2312", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.8331, "name_sim": 0.6966, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR1103", "Project Name": "Tradewater US - ODS - #7", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACR Destruction of Ozone Depleting Substances and High-GWP Foam", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 67978, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2024": 67978 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2312", "Project Name": "Tradewater ODS 68", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Listed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozone Depleting Substances Projects (ODS)", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [], "differences": [], "reason": "", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR1107~CAR2312", "a": "ACR1107", "b": "CAR2312", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.8331, "name_sim": 0.6966, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR1107", "Project Name": "Tradewater US - ODS - #8", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACR Destruction of Ozone Depleting Substances and High-GWP Foam", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 68178, "Total Credits Retired": 36156, "issued_by_vintage": { "2024": 68178 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2312", "Project Name": "Tradewater ODS 68", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Listed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozone Depleting Substances Projects (ODS)", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [], "differences": [], "reason": "", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR1117~CAR2312", "a": "ACR1117", "b": "CAR2312", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.8312, "name_sim": 0.693, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR1117", "Project Name": "Tradewater US - ODS - #9", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACR Destruction of Ozone Depleting Substances and High-GWP Foam", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 133280, "Total Credits Retired": 110485, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 133280 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2312", "Project Name": "Tradewater ODS 68", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Listed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozone Depleting Substances Projects (ODS)", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [], "differences": [], "reason": "", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR0193~CAR1026", "a": "ACR0193", "b": "CAR1026", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.8281, "name_sim": 0.6874, "overlap_vintages": [ 2014 ], "overlap_volume": 33214, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0193", "Project Name": "EOS ARB ODS 2013-7", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "Country": "United States", "State": "ARKANSAS", "Project Site Location": "El Dorado", "Project Developer": "EOS Climate Inc", "Total Credits Issued": 84418, "Total Credits Retired": 84418, "issued_by_vintage": { "2014": 84418 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR1026", "Project Name": "EOS ARB ODS 2014-2", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "Country": "United States", "State": "ARKANSAS", "Project Site Location": "El Dorado", "Project Developer": "EOS Climate Inc.", "Total Credits Issued": 33214, "Total Credits Retired": 33214, "issued_by_vintage": { "2014": 33214 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "no", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "EOS Climate Inc", "value_b": "EOS Climate Inc." }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / ARKANSAS / El Dorado", "value_b": "United States / ARKANSAS / El Dorado" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "value_b": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances起こ", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances起こ" }, { "field": "Status", "value_a": "Completed", "value_b": "Completed" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR0193 vs CAR CAR1026", "Name: EOS ARB ODS 2013-7 vs EOS ARB ODS 2014-2", "Credits issued by vintage: 2014:84418 vs 2014:33214" ], "reason": "The listings have different Registry / IDs, Names, and Credits issued by vintage.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR1147~CAR2157", "a": "ACR1147", "b": "CAR2157", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.8072, "name_sim": 0.6494, "overlap_vintages": [ 2025 ], "overlap_volume": 51771, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR1147", "Project Name": "Tradewater ODS 60", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Listed - Active ECY Project", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozone Depleting Substances Projects (ODS)", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 59104, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 59104 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2157", "Project Name": "Tradewater ODS 64", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozone Depleting Substances Projects (ODS)", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 51771, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 51771 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "no", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Tradewater, LLC", "value_b": "Tradewater LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool", "value_b": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "value_b": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozone Depleting Substances Projects (ODS)", "value_b": "ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozone Depleting Substances Projects (ODS)" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR1147 vs CAR CAR2157", "Name: Tradewater ODS 60 vs Tradewater ODS 64", "Status: Listed - Active ECY Project vs Registered", "Credits issued by vintage: 2025:59104 vs 2025:51771" ], "reason": "The listings have different Registry / IDs, Names, Statuses, and Credits issued by vintage.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR1173~CAR2157", "a": "ACR1173", "b": "CAR2157", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.8026, "name_sim": 0.641, "overlap_vintages": [ 2025 ], "overlap_volume": 51771, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR1173", "Project Name": "Tradewater US - ODS - #11", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACR Destruction of Ozone Depleting Substances and High-GWP Foam", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 87275, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 87275 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2157", "Project Name": "Tradewater ODS 64", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozone Depleting Substances Projects (ODS)", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 51771, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 51771 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "no", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Tradewater, LLC", "value_b": "Tradewater LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool", "value_b": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "value_b": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR1173 vs CAR CAR2157", "Name: Tradewater US - ODS - #11 vs Tradewater ODS 64", "Methodology: ACR Destruction of Ozone Depleting Substances and High-GWP Foam vs ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozonexml", "Credits issued by vintage: 2025:87275 vs 2025:51771" ], "reason": "The listings have different Registry / IDs, Names, Methodologies, and Credits issued by vintage.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR1219~CAR2157", "a": "ACR1219", "b": "CAR2157", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.8013, "name_sim": 0.6388, "overlap_vintages": [ 2025 ], "overlap_volume": 19376, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR1219", "Project Name": "Tradewater US - ODS - #13", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACR Destruction of Ozone Depleting Substances and High-GWP Foam", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 19376, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 19376 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2157", "Project Name": "Tradewater ODS 64", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozone Depleting Substances Projects (ODS)", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 51771, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 51771 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "no", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Tradewater, LLC", "value_b": "Tradewater LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool", "value_b": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "value_b": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR1219 vs CAR CAR2157", "Name: Tradewater US - ODS - #13 vs Tradewater ODS 64", "Methodology: ACR Destruction of Ozone Depleting Substances and High-GWP Foam vs ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozonexml", "Credits issued by vintage: 2025:19376 vs 2025:51771" ], "reason": "The listings have different Registry IDs, Names, Methodologies, and Credits issued by vintage.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR1147~CAR2152", "a": "ACR1147", "b": "CAR2152", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.8006, "name_sim": 0.6375, "overlap_vintages": [ 2025 ], "overlap_volume": 59104, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR1147", "Project Name": "Tradewater ODS 60", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Listed - Active ECY Project", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozone Depleting Substances Projects (ODS)", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 59104, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 59104 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2152", "Project Name": "Tradewater ODS 63", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozone Depleting Substances Projects (ODS)", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 138000, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 138000 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "no", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Tradewater, LLC", "value_b": "Tradewater LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool", "value_b": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "value_b": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozone Depleting Substances Projects (ODS)", "value_b": "ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozone Depleting Substances Projects (ODS)" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR1147 vs CAR CAR2152", "Name: Tradewater ODS 60 vs Tradewater ODS 63", "Status: Listed - Active ECY Project vs Registered", "Credits issued by vintage: 2025:59104 vs 2025:138000" ], "reason": "The listings have different Registry / IDs, Names, Statuses, and Credits issued by vintage.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR1173~CAR2257", "a": "ACR1173", "b": "CAR2257", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.7961, "name_sim": 0.6292, "overlap_vintages": [ 2025 ], "overlap_volume": 87092, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR1173", "Project Name": "Tradewater US - ODS - #11", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACR Destruction of Ozone Depleting Substances and High-GWP Foam", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 87275, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 87275 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2257", "Project Name": "Tradewater ODS 66", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozone Depleting Substances Projects (ODS)", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 87092, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 87092 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "no", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Tradewater, LLC", "value_b": "Tradewater LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool", "value_b": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "value_b": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR1173 vs CAR CAR2257", "Name: Tradewater US - ODS - #11 vs Tradewater ODS 66", "Methodology: ACR Destruction of Ozone Depleting Substances and High-GWP Foam vs ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozonexml", "Credits issued by vintage: 2025:87275 vs 2025:87092" ], "reason": "The listings have different Registry / IDs, Names, Methodologies, and Credits issued by vintage.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR1124~CAR2153", "a": "ACR1124", "b": "CAR2153", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.7955, "name_sim": 0.6282, "overlap_vintages": [ 2025 ], "overlap_volume": 198196, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR1124", "Project Name": "Tradewater US - ODS - #10", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACR Destruction of Ozone Depleting Substances and High-GWP Foam", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 198196, "Total Credits Retired": 85334, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 198196 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2153", "Project Name": "Tradewater ODS 62", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozone Depleting Substances Projects (ODS)", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 315246, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 315246 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Tradewater, LLC", "value_b": "Tradewater LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool", "value_b": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "value_b": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR1124 vs CAR CAR2153", "Name: Tradewater US - ODS - #10 vs Tradewater ODS 62", "Methodology: ACR Destruction of Ozone Depleting Substances and High-GWP Foam vs ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozonexml", "Status: Completed vs Registered" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a project developed by Tradewater LLC in East Liverpool, Ohio, involving Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR0184~CAR992", "a": "ACR0184", "b": "CAR992", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.7953, "name_sim": 0.6278, "overlap_vintages": [ 2013 ], "overlap_volume": 107542, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0184", "Project Name": "EOS ACR 2013", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "Country": "United States", "State": "ARKANSAS", "Project Site Location": "El Dorado", "Project Developer": "EOS Climate Inc", "Total Credits Issued": 249025, "Total Credits Retired": 249025, "issued_by_vintage": { "2013": 249025 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR992", "Project Name": "EOS ARB ODS 2013-1", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "Country": "United States", "State": "ARKANSAS", "Project Site Location": "El Dorado", "Project Developer": "EOS Climate Inc.", "Total Credits Issued": 107542, "Total Credits Retired": 107542, "issued_by_vintage": { "2013": 107542 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "no", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "EOS Climate Inc", "value_b": "EOS Climate Inc." }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / ARKANSAS / El Dorado", "value_b": "United States / ARKANSAS / El Dorado" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "value_b": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances起こ", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances起こ" }, { "field": "Status", "value_a": "Completed", "value_b": "Completed" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR0184 vs CAR CAR992", "Name: EOS ACR 2013 vs EOS ARB ODS 2013-1", "Credits issued by vintage: 2013:249025 vs 2013:107542" ], "reason": "The listings have different Registry / IDs, Names, and Credits issued by vintage.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR1124~CAR2257", "a": "ACR1124", "b": "CAR2257", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.7934, "name_sim": 0.6243, "overlap_vintages": [ 2025 ], "overlap_volume": 87092, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR1124", "Project Name": "Tradewater US - ODS - #10", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACR Destruction of Ozone Depleting Substances and High-GWP Foam", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 198196, "Total Credits Retired": 85334, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 198196 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2257", "Project Name": "Tradewater ODS 66", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozone Depleting Substances Projects (ODS)", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 87092, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 87092 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "no", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Tradewater, LLC", "value_b": "Tradewater LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool", "value_b": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "value_b": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR1124 vs CAR CAR2257", "Name: Tradewater US - ODS - #10 vs Tradewater ODS 66", "Methodology: ACR Destruction of Ozone Depleting Substances and High-GWP Foam vs ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozonexml", "Credits issued by vintage: 2025:198196 vs 2025:87092" ], "reason": "The listings have different Registry IDs, Names, Methodologies, and Credits issued by vintage.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR0184~CAR995", "a": "ACR0184", "b": "CAR995", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.7927, "name_sim": 0.623, "overlap_vintages": [ 2013 ], "overlap_volume": 122800, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0184", "Project Name": "EOS ACR 2013", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "Country": "United States", "State": "ARKANSAS", "Project Site Location": "El Dorado", "Project Developer": "EOS Climate Inc", "Total Credits Issued": 249025, "Total Credits Retired": 249025, "issued_by_vintage": { "2013": 249025 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR995", "Project Name": "EOS ARB ODS 2013-3", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "Country": "United States", "State": "ARKANSAS", "Project Site Location": "El Dorado", "Project Developer": "EOS Climate Inc.", "Total Credits Issued": 122800, "Total Credits Retired": 122800, "issued_by_vintage": { "2013": 122800 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "no", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "EOS Climate Inc", "value_b": "EOS Climate Inc." }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / ARKANSAS / El Dorado", "value_b": "United States / ARKANSAS / El Dorado" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "value_b": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances起こ", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances起こ" }, { "field": "Status", "value_a": "Completed", "value_b": "Completed" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR0184 vs CAR CAR995", "Name: EOS ACR 2013 vs EOS ARB ODS 2013-3", "Credits issued by vintage: 2013:249025 vs 2013:122800" ], "reason": "The listings have different Registry / IDs, Names, and Credits issued by vintage.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR0184~CAR1000", "a": "ACR0184", "b": "CAR1000", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.7911, "name_sim": 0.6201, "overlap_vintages": [ 2013 ], "overlap_volume": 126155, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0184", "Project Name": "EOS ACR 2013", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "Country": "United States", "State": "ARKANSAS", "Project Site Location": "El Dorado", "Project Developer": "EOS Climate Inc", "Total Credits Issued": 249025, "Total Credits Retired": 249025, "issued_by_vintage": { "2013": 249025 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR1000", "Project Name": "EOS ARB ODS 2013-5", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "Country": "United States", "State": "ARKANSAS", "Project Site Location": "El Dorado", "Project Developer": "EOS Climate Inc.", "Total Credits Issued": 126155, "Total Credits Retired": 126155, "issued_by_vintage": { "2013": 126155 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "no", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "EOS Climate Inc", "value_b": "EOS Climate Inc." }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / ARKANSAS / El Dorado", "value_b": "United States / ARKANSAS / El Dorado" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "value_b": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances起こ", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances起こ" }, { "field": "Status", "value_a": "Completed", "value_b": "Completed" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: ACR ACR0184 vs CAR CAR1000", "Name: EOS ACR 2013 vs EOS ARB ODS 2013-5", "Credits issued by vintage: 2013:249025 vs 2013:126155" ], "reason": "The listings have different Registry / IDs, Names, and Credits issued by vintage.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "CAR920~VCS638", "a": "CAR920", "b": "VCS638", "registry_a": "CAR", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.7846, "name_sim": 0.7901, "overlap_vintages": [ 2012, 2013, 2014 ], "overlap_volume": 31543, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "CAR920", "Project Name": "Rockingham County NC Landfill Gas Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Waste Management", "Type": "Landfill Methane", "Methodology / Protocol": "CAR U.S. Landfill Protocol", "Country": "United States", "State": "NORTH CAROLINA", "Project Site Location": "Rockingham County, NC", "Project Developer": "Rockingham County", "Total Credits Issued": 31543, "Total Credits Retired": 13203, "issued_by_vintage": { "2012": 8640, "2013": 19181, "2014": 3722 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS638", "Project Name": "Rockingham County Landfill Gas Combustion Project", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Waste Management", "Type": "Landfill Methane", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0001 Flaring or use of landfill gas", "Country": "United States", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Rockingham County", "Total Credits Issued": 343139, "Total Credits Retired": 252268, "issued_by_vintage": { "2010": 23850, "2011": 29857, "2012": 41249, "2013": 33058, "2014": 33400, "2015": 66682, "2016": 20260, "2017": 16338, "2018": 12345, "2019": 17376, "2020": 13502, "2021": 8712, "2022": 8788, "2023": 17722 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Rockingham County", "value_b": "Rockingham County" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Waste Management / Landfill Methane", "value_b": "Waste Management / Landfill Methane" }, { "field": "Country", "value_a": "United States", "value_b": "United States" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: CAR CAR920 vs VCS VCS638", "Name: Rockingham County NC Landfill Gas Project vs Rockingham County Landfill Gas Combustion Project", "Methodology: CAR U.S. Landfill Protocol vs ACM0001 Flaring or use of landfill gas", "Status: Completed vs Registered" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a Waste Management / Landfill Methane project developed by Rockingham County in the United States.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS12020~VCS3160", "a": "GS12020", "b": "VCS3160", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.7545, "name_sim": 0.7355, "overlap_vintages": [ 2022 ], "overlap_volume": 15317, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS12020", "Project Name": "Smokeless energy efficient cookstoves distribution in rural India-4", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "GS TPDDTEC Reduced emissions from cooking and heating – technologies and practices to displace decentralized thermal energy consumption", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "GRENEITY INFOCOM SERVICE PRIVATE LIMITED", "Total Credits Issued": 116038, "Total Credits Retired": 69499, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 15317, "2023": 43070, "2024": 37081, "2025": 20570 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS3160", "Project Name": "Distribution of energy efficient cookstoves in India-4", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Withdrawn", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "VMR0006 Energy Efficiency and Fuel Switch Measures in Thermal Applications", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Greneity Infocom Service Pvt Ltd", "Total Credits Issued": 99737, "Total Credits Retired": 63273, "issued_by_vintage": { "2021": 49619, "2022": 50118 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "no", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS12020 vs VCS VCS3160", "Name: Smokeless energy efficient cookstoves distribution in rural India-4 vs Distribution of energy efficient cookstoves", "Developer: GRENEITY INFOCOM SERVICE PRIVATE LIMITED vs Greneity Infocom Service Pvt Ltd", "Methodology: GS TPDDTEC Reduced emissions from cooking and heating – technologies and practices to displace and VMR0006" ], "reason": "The listings have different Registry IDs, Names, Developers, and Methodologies.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false }, { "id": "GS12018~VCS3158", "a": "GS12018", "b": "VCS3158", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.754, "name_sim": 0.7345, "overlap_vintages": [ 2022 ], "overlap_volume": 17574, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS12018", "Project Name": "Smokeless Energy efficient cookstoves distribution in Rural India-2", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "GS TPDDTEC Reduced emissions from cooking and heating – technologies and practices to displace decentralized thermal energy consumption", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "GRENEITY INFOCOM SERVICE PRIVATE LIMITED", "Total Credits Issued": 103458, "Total Credits Retired": 85174, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 17574, "2023": 34528, "2024": 33202, "2025": 18154 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS3158", "Project Name": "Distribution of energy efficient cookstoves in India-2", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Withdrawn", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "VMR0006 Energy Efficiency and Fuel Switch Measures in Thermal Applications", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Greneity Infocom Service Pvt Ltd", "Total Credits Issued": 243104, "Total Credits Retired": 128631, "issued_by_vintage": { "2021": 97394, "2022": 145710 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "no", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS12018 vs VCS VCS3158", "Name: Smokeless Energy efficient cookstoves distribution in Rural India-2 vs Distribution of energy efficient cookstoves", "Developer: GRENEITY INFOCOM SERVICE PRIVATE LIMITED vs Greneity Infocom Service Pvt Ltd", "Methodology: GS TPDDTEC Reduced emissions from cooking and heating – technologies and practices to displace and VMR0006" ], "reason": "The listings have different Registry / IDs, Names, Developers, and Methodologies.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false }, { "id": "GS12017~VCS3158", "a": "GS12017", "b": "VCS3158", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.7474, "name_sim": 0.7225, "overlap_vintages": [ 2022 ], "overlap_volume": 17189, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS12017", "Project Name": "Smokeless Energy efficient cookstoves distribution in Rural India", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "GS TPDDTEC Reduced emissions from cooking and heating – technologies and practices to displace decentralized thermal energy consumption", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "GRENEITY INFOCOM SERVICE PRIVATE LIMITED", "Total Credits Issued": 99580, "Total Credits Retired": 78940, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 17189, "2023": 33221, "2024": 31817, "2025": 17353 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS3158", "Project Name": "Distribution of energy efficient cookstoves in India-2", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Withdrawn", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "VMR0006 Energy Efficiency and Fuel Switch Measures in Thermal Applications", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Greneity Infocom Service Pvt Ltd", "Total Credits Issued": 243104, "Total Credits Retired": 128631, "issued_by_vintage": { "2021": 97394, "2022": 145710 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "no", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS12017 vs VCS VCS3158", "Name: Smokeless Energy efficient cookstoves distribution in Rural India vs Distribution of energy efficient cookstoves в", "Methodology: GS TPDDTEC Reduced emissions from cooking and heating – technologies and practices to displace decentalized", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Withdrawn" ], "reason": "The listings have different Registry / IDs, Names, Methodologies, and Statuses.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS12017~VCS3160", "a": "GS12017", "b": "VCS3160", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.7462, "name_sim": 0.7203, "overlap_vintages": [ 2022 ], "overlap_volume": 17189, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS12017", "Project Name": "Smokeless Energy efficient cookstoves distribution in Rural India", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "GS TPDDTEC Reduced emissions from cooking and heating – technologies and practices to displace decentralized thermal energy consumption", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "GRENEITY INFOCOM SERVICE PRIVATE LIMITED", "Total Credits Issued": 99580, "Total Credits Retired": 78940, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 17189, "2023": 33221, "2024": 31817, "2025": 17353 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS3160", "Project Name": "Distribution of energy efficient cookstoves in India-4", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Withdrawn", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "VMR0006 Energy Efficiency and Fuel Switch Measures in Thermal Applications", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Greneity Infocom Service Pvt Ltd", "Total Credits Issued": 99737, "Total Credits Retired": 63273, "issued_by_vintage": { "2021": 49619, "2022": 50118 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "no", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS12017 vs VCS VCS3160", "Name: Smokeless Energy efficient cookstoves distribution in Rural India vs Distribution of energy efficient cookstoves в", "Developer: GRENEITY INFOCOM SERVICE PRIVATE LIMITED vs Greneity Infocom Service Pvt Ltd", "Methodology: GS TPDDTEC Reduced emissions from cooking and heating – technologies and practices to displace decentalized" ], "reason": "The listings have different Registry / IDs, Names, Developers, and Methodologies.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS12020~VCS3158", "a": "GS12020", "b": "VCS3158", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.7444, "name_sim": 0.717, "overlap_vintages": [ 2022 ], "overlap_volume": 15317, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS12020", "Project Name": "Smokeless energy efficient cookstoves distribution in rural India-4", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "GS TPDDTEC Reduced emissions from cooking and heating – technologies and practices to displace decentralized thermal energy consumption", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "GRENEITY INFOCOM SERVICE PRIVATE LIMITED", "Total Credits Issued": 116038, "Total Credits Retired": 69499, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 15317, "2023": 43070, "2024": 37081, "2025": 20570 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS3158", "Project Name": "Distribution of energy efficient cookstoves in India-2", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Withdrawn", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "VMR0006 Energy Efficiency and Fuel Switch Measures in Thermal Applications", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Greneity Infocom Service Pvt Ltd", "Total Credits Issued": 243104, "Total Credits Retired": 128631, "issued_by_vintage": { "2021": 97394, "2022": 145710 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "no", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS12020 vs VCS VCS3158", "Name: Smokeless energy efficient cookstoves distribution in rural India-4 vs Distribution of energy efficient cookstoves", "Methodology: GS TPDDTEC vs VMR0006", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Withdrawn" ], "reason": "The listings have different Registry / IDs, Names, Methodologies, and Statuses.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS7620~VCS701", "a": "GS7620", "b": "VCS701", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.7364, "name_sim": 0.7025, "overlap_vintages": [ 2020, 2021, 2022 ], "overlap_volume": 60485, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS7620", "Project Name": "50.6 MW Wind Power Project at Umrali Gujarat by Powerica Limited", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": null, "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Powerica Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 601565, "Total Credits Retired": 133982, "issued_by_vintage": { "2020": 27935, "2021": 149587, "2022": 141870, "2023": 147078, "2024": 135095 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS701", "Project Name": "Wind power project at Gujarat by Powerica Limited", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "POWERICA LIMITED", "Total Credits Issued": 244452, "Total Credits Retired": 244452, "issued_by_vintage": { "2010": 16388, "2013": 23415, "2014": 22222, "2015": 24722, "2016": 24079, "2017": 25163, "2018": 24926, "2019": 23052, "2020": 18915, "2021": 21273, "2022": 20297 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "no", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Powerica Limited", "value_b": "POWERICA LIMITED" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS7620 vs VCS VCS701", "Name: 50.6 MW Wind Power Project at Umrali Gujarat by Powerica Limited vs Wind power project at Gujarat by Powerica 有限", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Registered", "Credits issued by vintage: 2020:27935, 2021:149587, 2022:141870, 2023:147078, 2024:135095 vs 2010:16388, 2013:23415, 201" ], "reason": "While both listings share the same Developer, Country, and Scope, they have different Registry IDs and different credits issued by vintage.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS12302~VCS2944", "a": "GS12302", "b": "VCS2944", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.7248, "name_sim": 0.6814, "overlap_vintages": [ 2022, 2023 ], "overlap_volume": 467233, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS12302", "Project Name": "Clean Cooking Program in Rural India", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": null, "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "EKI Energy Services Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 511108, "Total Credits Retired": 396704, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 4087, "2023": 463146, "2024": 43875 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS2944", "Project Name": "Clean Cookstoves for Rural India", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Verification approval requested", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "VMR0006 Energy Efficiency and Fuel Switch Measures in Thermal Applications; VM0050 Energy Efficiency and Fuel-Switch Measures in Cookstoves", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "EKI Energy Services Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 870015, "Total Credits Retired": 870015, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 164300, "2023": 705715 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "no", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "EKI Energy Services Limited", "value_b": "EKI Energy Services Limited" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS12302 vs VCS VCS2944", "Name: Clean Cooking Program in Rural India vs Clean Cookstoves for Rural India", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Verification approval requested", "Credits issued by vintage: 2022:4087, 2023:463146, 2024:43875 vs 2022:164300, 2023:705715" ], "reason": "The listings have different Registry / ID numbers and different credits issued by vintage.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS7469~VCS1830", "a": "GS7469", "b": "VCS1830", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.7142, "name_sim": 0.6621, "overlap_vintages": [ 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023 ], "overlap_volume": 68715, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS7469", "Project Name": "50.6 MW Wind Energy Project by Powerica Limited", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": null, "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Powerica Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 745400, "Total Credits Retired": 278141, "issued_by_vintage": { "2019": 92074, "2020": 131169, "2021": 136167, "2022": 127598, "2023": 134641, "2024": 123751 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1830", "Project Name": "Wind Power Project at Theni by Powerica Limited", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "POWERICA LIMITED", "Total Credits Issued": 172406, "Total Credits Retired": 147485, "issued_by_vintage": { "2010": 2722, "2011": 1213, "2012": 752, "2013": 17216, "2014": 15871, "2015": 11353, "2016": 19099, "2017": 18933, "2018": 16532, "2019": 15532, "2020": 15721, "2021": 15598, "2022": 16570, "2023": 5294 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "no", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Powerica Limited", "value_b": "POWERICA LIMITED" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS7469 vs VCS VCS1830", "Name: 50.6 MW Wind Energy Project by Powerica Limited vs Wind Power Project at Theni by Powerica Limited", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Registered", "Credits issued by vintage: 2019:92074, 2020:131169, 2021:136167, 2022:127598, 2023:134641, 2024:123751 vs 2010:2722, 201" ], "reason": "While both listings share the same developer, country, and scope, they have different Registry IDs, project names, and credit issuance histories.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS6832~VCS1784", "a": "GS6832", "b": "VCS1784", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.708, "name_sim": 0.9236, "overlap_vintages": [ 2019, 2020 ], "overlap_volume": 71348, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS6832", "Project Name": "50 MW Solar Power Project by Mytrah Energy India Private Limited", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Solar - Centralized", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "MYTRAH ENERGY (INDIA) PRIVATE LIMITED", "Total Credits Issued": 71348, "Total Credits Retired": 12763, "issued_by_vintage": { "2019": 20093, "2020": 51255 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1784", "Project Name": "Solar Power Project by Mytrah Energy India Private Limited", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Verification approval requested", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Solar - Centralized", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "JSW NEO ENERGY LIMITED", "Total Credits Issued": 3141114, "Total Credits Retired": 1507167, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 33067, "2018": 390627, "2019": 578461, "2020": 617428, "2021": 633723, "2022": 544516, "2023": 343292 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "no", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Solar - Centralized", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Solar - Centralized" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "value_b": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS6832 vs VCS VCS1784", "Name: 50 MW Solar Power Project by Mytrah Energy India Private Limited vs Solar Power Project by Mytrah Energy Indiawa", "Developer: MYTRAH ENERGY (INDIA) PRIVATE LIMITED vs JSW NEO ENERGY LIMITED", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Verification approval requested" ], "reason": "The listings differ in Registry / ID, Name, Developer, and Status.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS7469~VCS700", "a": "GS7469", "b": "VCS700", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.7004, "name_sim": 0.637, "overlap_vintages": [ 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023 ], "overlap_volume": 121371, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS7469", "Project Name": "50.6 MW Wind Energy Project by Powerica Limited", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": null, "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Powerica Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 745400, "Total Credits Retired": 278141, "issued_by_vintage": { "2019": 92074, "2020": 131169, "2021": 136167, "2022": 127598, "2023": 134641, "2024": 123751 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS700", "Project Name": "Wind power project at Tamilnadu by Powerica Limited", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "POWERICA LIMITED", "Total Credits Issued": 354701, "Total Credits Retired": 276337, "issued_by_vintage": { "2009": 7447, "2010": 38747, "2012": 411, "2013": 28283, "2014": 26219, "2015": 20798, "2016": 37006, "2017": 40700, "2018": 33719, "2019": 31940, "2020": 18398, "2021": 33721, "2022": 29618, "2023": 7694 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "no", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Powerica Limited", "value_b": "POWERICA LIMITED" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS7469 vs VCS VCS700", "Name: 50.6 MW Wind Energy Project by Powerica Limited vs Wind power project at Tamilnadu by Powerica Limited", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Registered", "Credits issued by vintage: 2019:92074, 2020:131169, 2021:136167, 2022:127598, 2023:134641, 2024:123751 vs 2009:7447, 201" ], "reason": "While both listings share the same Developer, Country, and Scope / Type, they have different Registry / IDs and different Credits issued by vintage.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS7629~VCS2243", "a": "GS7629", "b": "VCS2243", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.6892, "name_sim": 0.9803, "overlap_vintages": [ 2018, 2019 ], "overlap_volume": 38137, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.95, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS7629", "Project Name": "Wind power project in Madhya Pradesh (2) India", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Orange Renewable Power Pvt Ltd", "Total Credits Issued": 270342, "Total Credits Retired": 2254, "issued_by_vintage": { "2018": 1340, "2019": 69558, "2020": 61762, "2021": 70737, "2022": 66945 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS2243", "Project Name": "Wind power project in Madhya Pradesh, India", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Late to verify", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Ratedi Wind Power Private Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 125737, "Total Credits Retired": 125737, "issued_by_vintage": { "2016": 6729, "2017": 39311, "2018": 42900, "2019": 36797 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "value_b": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS7629 vs VCS VCS2243", "Developer: Orange Renewable Power Pvt Ltd vs Ratedi Wind Power Private Limited", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Late to verify", "Credits issued by vintage: 2018:1340, 2019:69558, 2020:61762, 2021:70737, 2022:66945 vs 2016:6729, 2017:39311, 2018:4290" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a Renewable Energy / Wind project using Methodology ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources in India / None / None.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "CAR509~VCS1888", "a": "CAR509", "b": "VCS1888", "registry_a": "CAR", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.6651, "name_sim": 0.876, "overlap_vintages": [ 2019 ], "overlap_volume": 2635, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "CAR509", "Project Name": "Larimer County Landfill Gas Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Waste Management", "Type": "Landfill Methane", "Methodology / Protocol": "CAR U.S. Landfill Protocol", "Country": "United States", "State": "COLORADO", "Project Site Location": "Larimer County, Colorado", "Project Developer": "Larimer Energy, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 184522, "Total Credits Retired": 165616, "issued_by_vintage": { "2009": 3408, "2010": 17110, "2011": 16616, "2012": 17024, "2013": 18452, "2014": 19036, "2015": 18232, "2019": 2635, "2020": 17907, "2021": 16757, "2022": 18584, "2023": 11398, "2024": 7363 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1888", "Project Name": "Larimer County Landfill Gas Flaring Project", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Late to verify", "Scope": "Waste Management", "Type": "Landfill Methane", "Methodology / Protocol": "Methodology Under Development", "Country": "United States", "State": "COLORADO", "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "3Degrees Group, Inc..", "Total Credits Issued": 84910, "Total Credits Retired": 84910, "issued_by_vintage": { "2016": 22201, "2017": 24510, "2018": 21923, "2019": 16276 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country / State", "value_a": "United States / COLORADO", "value_b": "United States / COLORADO" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Waste Management / Landfill Methane", "value_b": "Waste Management / Landfill Methane" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: CAR CAR509 vs VCS VCS1888", "Name: Larimer County Landfill Gas Project vs Larimer County Landfill Gas Flaring Project", "Developer: Larimer Energy, LLC vs 3Degrees Group, Inc..", "Methodology: CAR U.S. Landfill Protocol vs Methodology Under Development" ], "reason": "While both listings describe a Waste Management / Landfill Methane project in United States / COLORADO, they differ in Registry / ID, Name, Developer, and Methodology.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false }, { "id": "GS7664~VCS2059", "a": "GS7664", "b": "VCS2059", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.6282, "name_sim": 0.7483, "overlap_vintages": [ 2021, 2022 ], "overlap_volume": 460154, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS7664", "Project Name": "250 MW Solar PV Plant by Mahindra Renewables in Rajasthan", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Solar - Centralized", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Mahindra Susten Private Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 867303, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2021": 287677, "2022": 579626 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS2059", "Project Name": "Renewable Solar Power Project by Mahindra Renewables Private Limited", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Solar - Centralized", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Mahindra Renewables Private Limited.", "Total Credits Issued": 1355158, "Total Credits Retired": 629953, "issued_by_vintage": { "2018": 23196, "2019": 228222, "2020": 464178, "2021": 467085, "2022": 172477 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Mahindra Susten Private Limited", "value_b": "Mahindra Renewables Private Limited" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Solar - Centralized", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Solar - Centralized" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "value_b": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS7664 vs VCS VCS2059", "Name: 250 MW Solar PV Plant by Mahindra Renewables in Rajasthan vs Renewable Solar Power Project by Mahindra Renewables", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Registered", "Credits issued by vintage: 2021:287677, 2022:579626 vs 2018:23196, 2019:228222, 2020:464178, 2021:467085, 2022:172477" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a Renewable Energy / Solar - Centralized project in India using Methodology ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources developed by Mahindra Renewables.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS7532~VCS1805", "a": "GS7532", "b": "VCS1805", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.6251, "name_sim": 0.7184, "overlap_vintages": [ 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023 ], "overlap_volume": 2020932, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS7532", "Project Name": "200 MW solar power project in India by SB Energy.", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Solar - Centralized", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Adani Green Energy Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 2020932, "Total Credits Retired": 1105566, "issued_by_vintage": { "2019": 228168, "2020": 463807, "2021": 459836, "2022": 421244, "2023": 447877 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1805", "Project Name": "Solar Energy Project(s) by SB Energy Private Limited", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Solar - Centralized", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Adani Renewable Energy Devco Private Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 9446114, "Total Credits Retired": 6468476, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 521071, "2018": 810552, "2019": 626090, "2020": 1519558, "2021": 1877353, "2022": 2514594, "2023": 1576896 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "no", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Solar - Centralized", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Solar - Centralized" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "value_b": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS7532 vs VCS VCS1805", "Name: 200 MW solar power project in India by SB Energy vs Solar Energy Project(s) by SB Energy Private Limited", "Developer: Adani Green Energy Limited vs Adani Renewable Energy Devco Private Limited", "Credits issued by vintage: 2019:228168, 2020:463807, 2021:459836, 2022:421244, 2023:447877 vs 2017:521071, 2018:810552, " ], "reason": "The listings have different Registry / IDs, Developers, and Credits issued by vintage.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS4426~VCS1081", "a": "GS4426", "b": "VCS1081", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.6216, "name_sim": 0.6757, "overlap_vintages": [ 2014, 2015, 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022 ], "overlap_volume": 147534, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS4426", "Project Name": "Wind Energy Project in Gujarat", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Wind World (India) Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 1040870, "Total Credits Retired": 326581, "issued_by_vintage": { "2014": 65197, "2015": 96753, "2016": 79666, "2017": 150931, "2018": 186142, "2019": 181908, "2020": 136864, "2021": 78679, "2022": 64730 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1081", "Project Name": "Clean Energy Generation in Gujarat, India", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Wind World Wind Resources Development Private Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 188634, "Total Credits Retired": 188634, "issued_by_vintage": { "2011": 4855, "2012": 20515, "2013": 15730, "2014": 17560, "2015": 20088, "2016": 16127, "2017": 16096, "2018": 17863, "2019": 19248, "2020": 14979, "2021": 16700, "2022": 8873 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "no", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS4426 vs VCS VCS1081", "Name: Wind Energy Project in Gujarat vs Clean Energy Generation in Gujarat, India", "Developer: Wind World (India) Limited vs Wind World Wind Resources Development Private Limited", "Methodology: ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources vs AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewableসর" ], "reason": "The listings have different Registry IDs, Developers, and Methodologies.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false } ] }